Best American Restaurants in Bay Harbor Islands

Outstanding hospitality laced with authenticity throughout the food, with wonderful execution. A true gem without any pretentiousness. Go!

The staff was very attentive and fun. The food was excellent, and I loved the complementary Prosecco.

My experience was so incredible here at Morton’s! I came to celebrate my boyfriend’s 25th birthday and our server made our experience so special. He was very attentive, made thoughtful recommendations, and made us feel like VIPs. I wasn’t sure what I wanted to drink but knew I wanted a martini to start and a glass of wine with dinner- our waiter made me the most delicious passionfruit martini just to meet the flavor profile I was looking for (as it wasn’t on the menu). He also recommended the bacon wrapped scallops which were so delicious, a must try. For dinner we both had the fillet minion cooked perfectly medium rare- serious applause to the chef. The ambiance was romantic and classy, and since it’s December and close to Christmas, the tree and lights were up which really added such a beautiful touch. Lastly, to really put the cherry on top, our wonderful waiter treated us with a delicious chocolate molten lava cake with vanilla ice cream and raspberries (mouthwatering, another must try), and then he even took our photo for us, printed it and put it in a frame that said happy birthday inside! SO SPECIAL! Thank you “Nebraska”, we can’t wait to see you again and are so grateful for the beautiful experience and memory you gave us!

I took my mom for her birthday, It was our first time going and it succeeded all expectations. We were amazed with the quality of the food and the service. Our server was Alberto but all the other staff was amazing as well. They even brought a complementary drink for her birthday and made sure her day was special. I definitely recommend this place and will be going back🤍🤍

Great view nice selection Good service We would return here for sure