Best American Restaurants in Fort Myers Beach

We had a delicious brunch at Cooper's hawk today. The avocado toast and creme brulee french toast were yummy and the rockstar mimosa and cranberry spritz were awesome. My teen daughter really enjoyed her meal as well as her "no-mosa." Great non-alcoholic option! Our server, Sean(sp), was very attentive and friendly. Best service I've had recently.

Delicious as usual. Always good to be back at the pink shell and know that we don’t have to go anywhere for a great dinner!

Our server Josalyn , only 18 and a criminal justice major in junior college, is soo personable and friendly but so efficient and timely with our drinks and courses that it just made our 38th anniversary dinner a wonderful experience to remember! And I cannot thank our hostess enough who arranged a special table indoors for us on literally 2 hours’ notice, when I realized we had driven almost 400 miles the day before,planning to celebrate at Connors and I had thought I had made the reservation but had not! Everyone else treated us royally as well. This is one place where “same old, same old….” Is a GOOD thing, like each time in the past. We now plan to dine at Connors at least once every time we come near Sanibel or Ft Myers. Last year in December, even drove down from Clearwater for the day

We started out our experience with a window seat, which gave us a great sunset view. We started our meal with the Wagyu meatballs with polenta wedges. The meatballs were absolutely delicious! The only complaint there is, you only get 3 meatballs. I had the filet mignon with basically mashed potatoes and asparagus. Steak cooked to a perfect medium rare and the fllavor was spot on. My wife had the chicken au jus, that came with wild mushrooms and fingerling potatoes. She absolutely loved every bite she took. Chicken was juicy with crisp skin and the au jus sauce was perfect. We then decided to end the meal with a piece of key lime pie, let me tell you, it is fantastic! The restaurant itself was very clean and very well staffed. We had a great server named David that was on top of everything we needed. I would highly recommend.

Much to our dismay a reservation for an advertised buffet with carving stations /extensive salad bar /appetizers/sides/ desserts became an omelette bar with breakfast sides -which though good , was not what we expected ! apparently the advertised Xmas Buffet was from two years ago and we barely made the cut for the breakfast buffet ! our reservation was for 11 AM and the breakfast Buffet stopped serving at 11 AM. We were seated since we showed our confirmed reservation! Staff was confused n it took a bit to sort it all out. Never have had trouble with open table reservation before but this was a mess!!!