Best American Restaurants in Pawling

Our new favorite spot! We’ve been there 3 times in December and each time we left full, and happy. The restaurant is in beautifully decorated rooms attached to an old mansion home (with adjacent catering halls). The service is wonderful with charismatic and professional servers. Dave was fantastic. The food is delicious and well balanced and there’s always lots of delicious options. They also have yummy house wine. We highly recommend!

Great meal and very festive atmosphere First time for my friends and they loved it

As usual, our recent Friday night dinner at Tilly's Table was excellent. We arrived at 5 p.m. and were greeted and seated immediately. Our waitress came by and knew exactly which wine I would order. She brought over a small light which made our window seat much brighter. When it was time to order she joked with us, "The usual?" For me, yes. For my husband, no. He branched out to try another choice. The only problem we encountered was the table for two was hardly large enough to hold the large - and full - dinner and salad plates. We always have enough left on our plates to take home because of their enormous servings. So, actually, dinner at Tilly's is dinner a two-dinner affair.

Food and service both were fantastic Innovative and delicious food. Our group tried many different appetizers and main dishes and all were great. Service was very good. Our waiter Ari was attentive and informative without being at all overbearing This is our 5th or 6th meal here and it’s always great meal

Always excellent food, creative menu and great service