Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

129 restaurants available nearby

1. Yakar Steakhouse

5.0

Exceptional(24)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Midwood

Booked 2 times today

Yakar Steakhouse in Midwood, Brooklyn, is a beacon of Kosher dining, offering an unmatched steakhouse experience. Esteemed for its "Manhattan quality" right in the heart of Brooklyn, Yakar prides itself on serving the highest grade Prime meats, masterfully aged in their private dry aging room. Patrons rave about the "insane Cowboy Steak" and the "welcoming, upscale yet rustic atmosphere." The Kosher cuisine here is not only about adherence to dietary laws but also about celebrating the richness of Jewish culinary traditions with a modern twist. As one reviewer exclaimed, "The food was divine, wholesome, and scrumptious!" making Yakar a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic and high-quality Kosher meal.

A photo of D Garden Caribbean Bar & Grill restaurant

2. D Garden Caribbean Bar & Grill

3.9

Excellent(167)

Price: Expensive

• American • Flatbush

Booked 1 time today

D Garden Caribbean Bar & Grill in Flatbush, Brooklyn, epitomizes the essence of exceptional Bar / Lounge / Bottle Service with a Caribbean twist. This vibrant spot is renowned for its lively ambiance and expertly crafted cocktails. Guests rave about the "amazing drinks" and "great vibes," making it a must-visit for a spirited night out. The daily Happy Hour and weekend brunch specials, featuring unlimited mimosas and Bellinis, draw in a cheerful crowd, eager to unwind and indulge. Reviewers consistently praise the attentive service, with one noting, "the bartender Andre is great!! The rum punch always packs a punch." D Garden's festive atmosphere and standout mixology are celebrated by locals and visitors alike, securing its place as a beloved social hub in Brooklyn.

3. PiCH

3.5

Very Good(81)

Price: Moderate

• American • Flatbush

Booked 1 time today

PiCH in Flatbush, Brooklyn, redefines American cuisine with its vibrant Caribbean twist, making it a culinary gem. This hotspot is celebrated for its impeccable service and the authentic flavors that permeate dishes like the jerk wings, jerk tacos, and the delectably unique Mac n cheese. Guests rave about their experiences, noting, "PiCH is by far the best restaurant in Flatbush right now!" and praising the "authentic blueberry syrup" in their standout blueberry margaritas. The fusion of American and Caribbean delights in a lively atmosphere, complete with themed nights and a DJ, ensures a memorable dining adventure for anyone looking for quality and authenticity in every bite.

4. The Odeon

4.8

Exceptional(3620)

Price: Expensive

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 123 times today

At The Odeon in TriBeCa, New York, the essence of French cuisine is brought to life with an impeccable touch of local flair. This iconic New York establishment, celebrated for its consistent excellence, offers a menu where each dish is a testament to authentic French flavors. Guests rave about the "best onion soup ever" and the "crazy good veggie nicoise," highlighting the quality and authenticity that The Odeon prides itself on. A patron enthused, "I’m French and I approve ;-)," underscoring the genuine French culinary experience. With its vibrant ambiance and stellar service, The Odeon stands as a beacon of French gastronomy in the heart of New York, making every dining experience memorable and true to its roots.

5. The River Cafe

4.9

Exceptional(9174)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • DUMBO

Booked 22 times today

The River Café is one of New York and America’s most unique locations. Nestled under the Brooklyn Bridge with sweeping views of the New York skyline and the Statue of Liberty, this elegant restaurant has, since 1977, been a favorite destination for New Yorkers and visitors from around the world who demand the highest level of cuisine. Renowned for its exquisite setting, beautiful decor and seamless service The River Café serves a wonderful classic New American menu using only the finest, freshest and often rare ingredients. With an award winning and outstanding wine list, romantic piano music nightly, breathtaking floral arrangements, the River Café is more than simply dining, it is often a magical experience. Whether you are coming for dinner or a private party, be sure to leave some time to enjoy The River Café’s spectacular garden.

6. Fraunces Tavern

4.6

Exceptional(2998)

Price: Expensive

• American • Financial District

Booked 120 times today

Fraunces Tavern Restaurant, est. 1762, is a historic landmark in FiDi. Offering small batch craft & specialty beers, handcrafted cocktails, & 1000+ spirits, experience the delectable flavors of thoughtfully prepared American cuisine, featuring our farm-to-table ingredients. The establishment boasts 7 distinct spaces, each providing exceptional options for both public & private experiences alike. Invite friends to sit around the warm fire in the Dingle Whiskey Bar or gather & mingle in The Wine Room. Host a formal event under the crystal chandeliers in the Washington Room for a private dining experience. Whether you prefer the Independence or Hideout Bar, both offer a fun and informal atmosphere to enjoy happy hour with friends. Experience the secluded charm of The Piano Bar Upstairs, to enjoy exquisite food, drinks, and live music in a relaxed atmosphere. If you're a history buff, visit the Bissell room to view the beautiful mural painting depicting downtown NYC in the 1700s.

7. Strange Delight

4.7

Exceptional(107)

Price: Expensive

• American • Fort Greene

Booked 27 times today

Strange Delight in Fort Greene, Brooklyn, delivers an exceptional Southern culinary experience, blending New Orleans charm with New York's rich oyster heritage. This restaurant dazzles with dishes like "NOLA-spot on chargrilled oysters" and the "perfectly crafted Japanese style sando" shrimp sandwich, leaving patrons raving about the authenticity and flavor. A standout is the Blackened Swordfish Belly, a dish so memorable that guests plan return visits just to savor it again. The Hurricane and Ramos Gin Fizz cocktails complement the seafood perfectly, enhancing the vibrant atmosphere. As one satisfied customer put it, Strange Delight is "a home away from Nawlins," making it a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Southern delights in a contemporary setting.

8. The Crosby Bar

4.6

Exceptional(897)

Price: Expensive

• American • SoHo

Booked 51 times today

Nestled in the charming streets of SoHo, New York, The Crosby Bar & Terrace epitomizes the epitome of modern American cuisine with its vibrant ambiance and exquisite menu. Patrons consistently rave about its "best afternoon tea in NY" and commend the "wonderful service and great location." The Crosby Bar excels in delivering an authentic American dining experience with a menu that includes everything from impeccable omelets to lobster linguine, all served in a setting that features high ceilings and a leafy, breezy feel. Reviewers highlight the "perfect service" and "delicious food," making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a quintessential American meal in a beautifully designed space. Whether it's for a special occasion or a casual meet-up, The Crosby Bar remains a beloved staple for both locals and visitors alike.

A photo of Warren Street Bar and Restaurant restaurant

9. Warren Street Bar and Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(51)

Price: Expensive

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 17 times today

The Warren Street Bar & Restaurant is a modern, neighbourhood brasserie offering an all-day menu of much-loved classics and fresh, seasonal dishes filled with flavours and ingredients from around the world. The space itself is a celebration of colour and creativity, with an eclectic art collection and characterful interiors.

10. Chambers

4.9

Exceptional(545)

Price: Moderate

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 22 times today

At Chambers in TriBeCa, New York, the essence of American cuisine is elevated to sublime heights. Described by guests as "absolute perfection," the restaurant skillfully combines a minimalistic ambiance with robust, seasonal flavors that captivate the palate. Patrons rave about standout dishes like the "silkily prepared sirloin with chimichurri" and the "flavor-packed squid and sweetbreads," each beautifully presented and bursting with taste. The beverage program is equally impressive, with a wine selection "second to none," passionately curated by the renowned sommelier Pascaline. Chambers is celebrated for its "unpretentious and comfortable" atmosphere, making it not just a meal but a cherished dining experience in the heart of NYC.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Mel
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined today
As always the Thanksgiving dinner at The Odeon was incredible. Great food and service. It’s become a yearly tradition!
More info
The OdeonPrice: Expensive• French• TriBeCa
•
4.8
L
Lisavip
Greater Boston •359 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
The River Cafe is my favorite restaurant in New York, and probably anywhere else too! The beautiful romantic atmosphere, amazing views, warm yet attentive service and truly exquisite food make for a perfect experience. It is a special occasion place, not for everyday, but we have celebrated our anniversary there several times (when in the city - we do not live in NYC), and this time it was our 50th. They did not disappoint! I hope I get to go back for many more special occasions. We took our adult son with us and he loved it as well.
More info
The River CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• DUMBO
•
4.9
B
Betty
New York City •1 review
4.0
Dined 5 days ago
The Mac n cheese was delicious tasted southern not like “macaroni pie’ chicken tenders were juicy too
More info
PiCHPrice: Moderate• Caribbean• Flatbush
•
3.5
S
Sheree
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on Nov 21, 2024
My best friend and I stopped here for a very needed girls night after a longgggg work day and it was such a vibe! The atmosphere was perfect—great energy, music that set the mood, and a trendy yet chill setting. We tried a little bit of everything since we read the reviews and settled for the jerk chicken, tacos and wings, and the curry goat. Every dish was REALLLLLLY GOOD. The jerk chicken had a lot of flavor and wasn’t too spicy which we liked, the tacos and wings wad a good starter, the curry goat was tender and delicious. The drinks were trendy and tasty—definitely a highlight of the night. Whether you’re out with your bestie or just want good food and drinks, this spot won’t disappoint. We’ll absolutely be back.
More info
D Garden Caribbean Bar & GrillPrice: Expensive• Caribbean• Flatbush
•
3.9
H
Herman
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on Oct 29, 2024
Wow, this restaurant was just incredible! The food was beyond delicious, and the service was truly amazing. From the moment we walked in to the very last bite, everything was top-notch. I'm already looking forward to going back for more of that fantastic experience!
More info
Yakar SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Kosher• Midwood
•
5

Explore OpenTable

Sheepshead Bay

American

Best American Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

129 restaurants available nearby

1. Yakar Steakhouse

2. D Garden Caribbean Bar & Grill

3. PiCH

4. The Odeon

5. The River Cafe

6. Fraunces Tavern

7. Strange Delight

8. The Crosby Bar

9. Warren Street Bar and Restaurant

10. Chambers

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable