Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
10 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- BBridgetNew York City •1 review5.0Dined 7 days agoDelicious food and incredible service. Can’t wait to go back.More infoVine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island•4.7
- PpennievipNew York City •12 reviews5.0Dined on Nov 15, 2024We went for a special for a 4 course dinner to raise money for Slow food East End. The food was above and beyond delicious sourcing all local farmers and fisherman. Everything was outstanding!  everything at Noah’s is a tribute to the area that we live in, and to the slow food, philosophy of good clean and fair food for allMore infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.5
- JJessicaNew York City •13 reviews4.0Dined on Nov 8, 2024Some dishes were very good a couple were lacking flavor making it just ok. Definitely small portions so if you are really hungry order extra. The food was average but the view is fantastic.More infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport•4.4
- JJimChicago / Illinois •29 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 24, 2024Great experience. Service and food first class. Pricey but well worth it. Hand duck, wife had chicken scallapini , son had bass. All outstanding. Some of the best service I ever hadMore infoThe North Fork Table & InnPrice: Very Expensive• Contemporary American• Southold•4.6
- MMattNew York City •22 reviews4.0Dined on Oct 20, 2024Clam chowder was great. Lobster pot pie (3 received) had a hard (what they called puff pastry) on top but it was as bad as Hartack! Beware of the parking out front. Our hosts told us the $5 parking fee was free if you eat there. Not true as we found out we each got an $88 ticket. If you don't have a phone you won't be able to pay the fee because there's only a QR Code to send you to their parking app. BTW, I spoke with Claudio's manager and he said they would have given us 50% off the parking fee if we had asked (how about a warning to be sure to pay for parking because it's highway robbery in fines!) Kind of leaves a sour taste in our mouths and not from the food!More infoClaudio's Tavern & GrillPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Greenport•3.9
Discover best American restaurants in Shelter Island
Discover the essence of American dining on Shelter Island, Suffolk, New York State, where a selection of restaurants offers a delightful exploration of local flavors and culinary innovations. Shelter Island's dining scene thrills with its emphasis on locally-sourced ingredients, reflecting the area's rich agricultural heritage and maritime resources. Each restaurant captures the essence of American cuisine, presenting a range of dishes from classic comfort foods to sophisticated gourmet offerings. The atmosphere in these eateries varies from the cozy and intimate to the elegantly casual, ensuring a setting that complements any dining experience. Not only is the food a highlight, but the service is also noted for its attentiveness and warmth, enhancing the overall dining pleasure. As Shelter Island is a coveted destination, making reservations is advisable to secure a spot in these sought-after establishments. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these restaurants promise an unforgettable taste of American culinary excellence right in the heart of Suffolk.