Best American Restaurants in Whitefish Bay

Harry’s is my favorite restaurant. Walking distance, great food, nice ambience.

We had such a nice time on New Year’s Day at this local gem. Our waiter was the friendliest and we felt right at home and welcomed, especially on a holiday! Starting with the tater tots - these are amazing, homemade - and more like mashed potato consistency instead of shredded - they were so flavorful and the sauce was perfect! For the Brussels sprouts starter, we did think they were yummy - just wish that it wasn’t all deconstructed leaves (instead of the whole sprout) - it was still crunchy salty delicious! I ordered the salmon Main, which I did enjoy - everything was cooked perfectly. Salmon was juicy and well seasoned, the asparagus grilled and the pearled couscous had amazing curry flavors - which doesn’t seem like it would work with the lobster bisque for a base sauce- but it did! Highly recommend this place. Great ambiance, service and food.

Birch is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, the service was outstanding. The food? Simply some of the best we’ve ever had! Every dish was a masterpiece with flavors that blew us away. You can tell how much thought and care goes into every ingredient. Their in-house pastry chef is a true artist. Make sure to save room for dessert; you won’t regret it! The drinks were fantastic as well—expertly crafted and the perfect complement to our meal. Highly recommend!

Our server couldn’t have been better. Her name was Alex. Delicious salmon sandwich.

Group of 7 sat at high top in the bar. Our server, Nick, provided great service and made recommendations ( all good). Ordered appetizers and dinners ranged from bread bowl soup, fish tacos, salmon entree. All delicious. Has been open only 4 weeks but well run establishment since they have a few Mallards restaurants in MN. Definitely worth trying if you are looking for a new restaurant!