Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York City

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Theater District

Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility

64 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Max Brenner - Union Square restaurant
1. Max Brenner - Union Square
4.2
Awesome(8143)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Union Square
Booked 47 times today
Max Brenner - Union Square offers a delightful journey into the heart of Contemporary American cuisine with a distinct chocolate twist. Located in the vibrant Union Square of New York, this restaurant is a haven for both locals and tourists seeking a unique dining experience. "The food is consistently excellent," praised one reviewer, highlighting the impeccable quality of each dish. Known for its innovative menu, Max Brenner combines classic American favorites with a creative chocolate infusion that elevates the entire dining experience. Whether it's the savory breakfast options or the decadent desserts, every meal promises to "entice magical memories" and leave guests craving more.
A photo of Dolly Varden restaurant
2. Dolly Varden
4.3
Awesome(1065)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Hell's Kitchen
Booked 25 times today
Dolly Varden in Hell's Kitchen, New York, is a shining star of quality American cuisine. With its inviting atmosphere and expertly crafted cocktails, this vibrant neighborhood spot is beloved by locals and visitors alike. Reviews rave about the "crave-worthy comfort food" like the Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich and the melt-in-your-mouth Short Rib Grilled Cheese. Dolly Varden is praised for its exceptional service and the "super friendly staff" who make every visit memorable. The ambiance, described as a "cute vibe" with fantastic decor, enhances the dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic American flavors and good vibes.
A photo of Bubba Gump - New York restaurant
3. Bubba Gump - New York
4.0
Excellent(542)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Theater District
Booked 48 times today
Bubba Gump - New York, nestled in the heart of the Theater District, offers an authentic taste of American cuisine that delights diners with its southern-style comfort dishes. This vibrant eatery, inspired by the classic film "Forrest Gump," presents a menu brimming with mouthwatering options like sautéed shrimp, fried shrimp, and award-winning baby back ribs. Guests rave about the "amazing ambiance" and "fantastic experience," with the energetic atmosphere and friendly staff enhancing every visit. With its prime location in Times Square, Bubba Gump captures the essence of American dining, making it a "must-visit" for locals and tourists alike.
A photo of Bacall's restaurant
4. Bacall's
3.9
Excellent(1495)
Price: Expensive
• Comfort food • Theater District
Bacall's, nestled in the heart of New York's Theater District, offers a vibrant American dining experience that perfectly marries tradition with innovation. With a dynamic menu that evolves with the seasons, this brasserie delights guests with elevated classic dishes and a flair for the dramatic. Diners rave about the "generous portions" and "phenomenal" food, highlighting the delicious short rib and perfectly cooked steak frites. The restaurant's festive decor, described as "like from a movie," adds to the allure, making each visit memorable. Whether you're there for a pre-show dinner or a festive celebration, Bacall's promises an unforgettable American culinary journey.
A photo of Somewhere Nowhere NYC restaurant
5. Somewhere Nowhere NYC
4.4
Awesome(239)
Price: Very Expensive
• Comfort food • Chelsea
Booked 4 times today
Somewhere Nowhere NYC in Chelsea, New York, offers a top-tier Comfort Food experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. Nestled atop the Renaissance New York Chelsea Hotel, this vibrant venue perfectly combines magical decor with delectable dishes, making it a must-visit for comfort food aficionados. Guests rave about the "delicious" food and "fantastic" service, highlighting the venue's chicken tacos and Wagyu burger served with crispy fries as particularly "delectable." The stunning views of Manhattan's skyline enhance the dining experience, making it a "memorable night out" for anyone seeking both incredible comfort food and breathtaking scenery.
A photo of Bill's Bar and Burger restaurant
6. Bill's Bar and Burger
4.2
Awesome(2539)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Rockefeller Center
Booked 47 times today
Bill's Bar and Burger at Rockefeller Center is a beacon for authentic American cuisine in the heart of New York City. Known for its "excellent burgers" and "divine milkshakes," this bustling spot delivers a classic American dining experience that leaves patrons raving. The signature Bill’s ‘Fat Cat’ Burger has earned its place among CNN’s “Top 10 Burgers in America” and continues to receive accolades from local sources like The Daily Meal and Thrillist. Guests love the fun, family-friendly atmosphere, and the service is consistently praised as "great all the way around." Whether you're a local or a visitor, savoring a meal at Bill's is a must.
A photo of Lillie's Union Square restaurant
7. Lillie's Union Square
4.1
Excellent(640)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Chelsea
An Irish-Victorian Bar and Restaurant, just steps from Union Square. In the "Ladies' Mile District" of days gone by. The interior has a distinctly late 19th century feel with wooden furnishings brought from Belfast, Ireland.Serving a wide range of domestic and international beers 25 on tap. A great selection of whiskeys and wines, including some excellent wine from the Langtry Winery in California where Lillie herself owned and lived for a time.The food is traditional Pub Fare. Bottomless Brunch on weekends from 11am to 4pm. It includes Mimosas, Bloody Marys, Aperol Spritz, and Seasonal Bellinis. Our last seating for Bottomless is 3.00pm.
A photo of Carnegie Diner & Café – 205 W 57th St, New York, NY restaurant
8. Carnegie Diner & Café – 205 W 57th St, New York, NY
4.6
Exceptional(1903)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Midtown West
Booked 71 times today
Carnegie Diner & Café, nestled in the heart of Midtown West, New York, offers an unparalleled breakfast experience that captures the essence of a classic American diner. Known for its massive portions and organic ingredients, this spot is a must-visit for breakfast enthusiasts. Guests rave about the "super fresh" food and describe their breakfast experience as "the best breakfast experience by a country mile." The Nutella French Toast and Organic Egg Omelettes are standout favorites, praised for their "outstanding quantity and quality." The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service ensure diners "leave satisfied every time," making it a cherished breakfast destination.
A photo of Virgil's Real BBQ - New York City restaurant
9. Virgil's Real BBQ - New York City
4.4
Awesome(8026)
Price: Moderate
• Comfort food • Theater District
Booked 49 times today
Virgil's Real BBQ in New York City is a true gem for lovers of authentic American cuisine, particularly if you're craving top-notch BBQ. Established in 1994, this restaurant has been recognized as one of America’s top 10 BBQ spots, thanks to its perfectly smoked meats, which are infused with flavors from a unique blend of hickory, oak, and fruit woods. Located in the heart of the Theater District, Virgil’s offers an inviting atmosphere and hearty portions that receive rave reviews. Diners celebrate its "outstanding ribs" and "delicious mac and cheese," making it a must-visit for anyone seeking genuine American flavors.
A photo of McHale's Bar & Grill restaurant
10. McHale's Bar & Grill
4.7
Exceptional(420)
Price: Very Expensive
• Comfort food • Theater District
Booked 6 times today
Voted best Irish Bar in New York City by the diner’s of OpenTable.Come join us soon for a wonderful dining experience!Call to make a reservation or walk on in! We have two floors with plenty of room for everyone.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Discover best Comfort Food restaurants in Theater District

Discover the ultimate comfort food destinations in Manhattan's bustling Theater District. Known for its vibrant cultural scene and proximity to Broadway, this area offers a diverse array of eateries specializing in comforting, hearty meals that cater to every palate. From Southern-style dishes and classic American fare to traditional Irish meals and innovative contemporary American cuisine, each restaurant provides a unique take on comfort food, ensuring there's something to satisfy all cravings. Patrons can expect generous portions, a welcoming atmosphere, and service that makes you feel right at home. Reviewers consistently praise the delicious food and outstanding service, highlighting the overall excellent dining experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot to unwind after a show or a lively venue to enjoy a meal with friends, the Theater District in New York City is a prime destination for comfort food lovers. Each restaurant's commitment to culinary excellence and a friendly, inviting environment makes it a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo