Best Italian Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands

17 restaurants available nearby

1. Pazzo Restaurant

4.4

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 24 times today

Pazzo is an Italian restaurant in Red Bank serving a variety of traditional menu items, along with several unique family recipes and other creative fare. Our Italian cuisine is made with the freshest ingredients from local farms and importers direct from Italy. Wines, craft beers and exclusive cocktails are paired with our dishes to enhance your dining experience. We also offer Gluten Free pizzas and pastas!

A photo of Semolina Restaurant restaurant

2. Semolina Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(3179)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 34 times today

Semolina Restaurant in Red Bank is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine, praised for its inventive use of local, fresh ingredients that elevate traditional Italian dishes to new heights. The farm-to-table approach ensures every dish bursts with flavor and authenticity, with "pasta dishes that are particularly fantastic," as diners rave. Guests highlight the "outstanding" service and the cozy, welcoming BYO atmosphere that complements the dining experience. The menu, which rotates seasonally, keeps patrons excited with each visit. Semolina's commitment to quality and creativity makes it a standout choice for anyone eager to indulge in exceptional Contemporary Italian dining.

A photo of Il Colosseo - New Jersey restaurant

3. Il Colosseo - New Jersey

4.8

Exceptional(861)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 8 times today

Il Colosseo in Red Bank, NJ, is a seafood lover's paradise, offering a delightful array of authentic Italian seafood dishes. Diners rave about their "spectacular" Seafood Salad, which sets the tone for a memorable meal. The Black Ravioli with Seafood is another standout, praised for its delicious flavors and perfect execution. The Scottish salmon dish, "perfectly cooked with a tasteful mango sauce," has received particular kudos from regulars. With impeccable service and a welcoming atmosphere, Il Colosseo ensures every visit is a culinary delight. Experience the exceptional seafood cuisine that keeps patrons returning again and again to this beloved establishment.

4. Buona Sera

4.7

Exceptional(1716)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 19 times today

(Online reservations for 5 or more, please call us)** 2 hour min required for Pre Count Basie show reservations. The classy and elegant Buona Sera is located in Red Bank area of New Jersey. The dining room is gorgeous with carefully planned details and decorations that add a sense of refinement to the restaurant. You can also host an event or party in the Wine Cellar or Tuscan Room. Catering services can be ordered for in-house reservations as well as for outside events. Buona Sera is a full service bar and restaurant, and our menu is quite extensive, giving you a lot of lunch and dinner options to choose from. Start off with one of the large and flavorful appetizers, then continue to the main course. Entrées at Buona Sera include pasta, veal, choice steaks, chicken, pork chops, various types of ravioli and seafood. Veal chops from this restaurant are some of the most popular dishes on the menu and are worth trying.

5. Elli’s Backyard

4.6

Exceptional(420)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 5 times today

Elli’s Backyard in Red Bank, NJ, is a dessert lover's paradise, offering an authentic taste experience that keeps diners coming back for more. Known for its “decadent flourless chocolate cake” and innovative “ice-cream soft choc chip cookie combo,” aptly named "the bomb," Elli's desserts are a highlight not to be missed. The restaurant's attention to detail and commitment to quality shine through in every sweet treat, providing delightful endings to their already impressive meals. The charming, backyard ambiance adds to the overall experience, making it a perfect spot for dessert enthusiasts seeking something truly special in Red Bank.

A photo of Monticello at Red Bank restaurant

6. Monticello at Red Bank

4.5

Awesome(1652)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 3 times today

Monticello at Red Bank is a beacon of authentic Mediterranean cuisine, setting a high standard with its commitment to fresh, non-GMO, and hormone-free ingredients. Diners rave about the "outstanding" flavors and "exceptionally fresh" dishes, often highlighting the unique garden-to-table experience from their onsite organic garden. Located in the heart of Red Bank, the restaurant offers an intimate and romantic ambiance, perfect for any occasion. The chef's philosophy of clean, Mediterranean eating is evident in every meticulously prepared dish, from the sumptuous seafood spaghettini to the exquisite poached pear salad. As one reviewer exclaims, "Every meal is a great meal from start to finish!"

7. Trattoria Toscana

4.0

Excellent(15)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Middletown

Booked 1 time today

Experience the Flavors of Tuscany at our Italian RestaurantExperience authentic Italian cuisine made with fresh ingredients accompanied by the best selection of wines. Our burger menu and wide array of meat choices transforms our Italian Restaurant into Italian steakhouse

A photo of Urban CoalHouse - Red Bank restaurant

8. Urban CoalHouse - Red Bank

4.6

Exceptional(423)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Red Bank

Booked 1 time today

Urban CoalHouse in Red Bank masterfully captures the essence of Italian cuisine, offering a delightful blend of tradition and creativity. The restaurant's standout feature is its authentic coal-fired pizzas, which patrons consistently rave about, calling them "better than ever" and "amazing." The signature menu is crafted with the freshest, highest quality ingredients, ensuring every bite is a genuine taste of Italy. With a welcoming atmosphere and a staff that's "on point," diners enjoy a complete Italian experience that goes beyond just the food. The restaurant also boasts a fantastic selection of craft beers and homemade sangria, enhancing the overall dining experience.

9. Trama's Trattoria

4.9

Exceptional(2409)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Long Branch

Booked 17 times today

Trama's Trattoria in Long Branch, NJ offers an exquisite journey into Contemporary Italian cuisine, celebrated for its "amazing food" and "wonderful service." Chef Trama's commitment to quality is evident in the fresh, farm-to-table ingredients that make each dish sing with seasonal flavor. Diners rave about the "luxurious" butternut squash on whipped ricotta and the "amazing" seven fishes fra diavolo. The restaurant's inviting ambiance and attentive service, often highlighted by standout staff like Sean and Andrew, ensure that every visit feels like a cherished gathering among friends. Trama's Trattoria is "hands down the best kept secret at the Jersey shore," offering a memorable dining experience.

A photo of Gargiulos Tinton Falls restaurant

10. Gargiulos Tinton Falls

4.8

Exceptional(1228)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Tinton Falls

Booked 8 times today

Gargiulos Tinton Falls is a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, seamlessly blending tradition with modern flair. This family-owned gem, steeped in over 50 years of culinary heritage, offers diners in Tinton Falls, NJ, a genuine taste of Italy without the need for a transcontinental journey. Guests rave about the "fantastic food," which consistently delivers delightful surprises from appetizers to desserts. The stuffed artichoke and scallop appetizers are especially praised as "phenomenal" by patrons. The ambiance is inviting, with an old-world charm that complements the exquisite dishes. Experience their "excellent service" and "authentic" flavors that make every meal memorable and satisfying.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Mary
Atlantic City / South Jersey Shore •3 reviews
4.0
Dined 2 days ago
We love how they decorate for Christmas but were disappointed that all the decorations were down and the vibe didn’t feel the same. We had a reservation but had to wait 25 minutes for our table. Our waiter was very curt and not attentive. This was such a dramatically different experience from our previous times and now not worth the almost hour drive. Was shocked by this and so disappointed. Frankly, all of the staff seemed grumpy!
More info
Buona SeraPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Red Bank
•
4.7
S
SueVIP
Pittsburgh / Western PA •13 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Consistently fabulous meal. The signature pork chop was amazing and the shaved Brussel Caesar salad delicious. Love the caramel mousse dessert. One of our favorite restaurants for a fantastic dinner.
More info
Semolina RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Farm-to-table• Red Bank
•
4.8
C
catherine
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Very good corn nuggets and shrimp salad. Best of all was our kind and friendly server.
More info
Elli’s BackyardPrice: Moderate• American• Red Bank
•
4.6
D
Deb
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
We ordered about 6 apps to start. They came out at different times. I thought it was a good thing. The stuffed artichoke was good. But tell the chef to add an egg ti the stuffing mix to help hold it together. As always the limoncello wings were great. Even the mozzarella squares were awesome. I had the regular short rib entree. It was to due for. Fork tender. Veggies were cooked to perfection, not mushy or over cooked. All and all, very pleasant experience
More info
Pazzo RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Italian• Red Bank
•
4.4
C
ChrissyVIP
New York City •22 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 28, 2024
We had to wait a while for our table- but we know it’s not the fault of the restaurant. People need to realize that they can’t linger at their table- especially when they are the early reservation. Pasquale and his team totally did right by us. It was a great dinner- fantastic drinks and food.
More info
Il Colosseo - New JerseyPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Red Bank
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Atlantic Highlands

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

17 restaurants available nearby

1. Pazzo Restaurant

2. Semolina Restaurant

3. Il Colosseo - New Jersey

4. Buona Sera

5. Elli’s Backyard

6. Monticello at Red Bank

7. Trattoria Toscana

8. Urban CoalHouse - Red Bank

9. Trama's Trattoria

10. Gargiulos Tinton Falls

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable