88 Best Italian Restaurants In Coney Island

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant

1. Gargiulo's Coney Island

4.6

Exceptional(827)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Coney Island

Booked 1 time today

Gargiulo's Coney Island offers an authentic journey into the heart of Contemporary Italian cuisine right in Brooklyn. Known for its "divine" traditional Neapolitan fare, Gargiulo’s combines family recipes that have delighted diners since 1907 with a modern twist. The restaurant is celebrated for its "phenomenal" dishes like pan-seared mozzarella and trofie pasta with pesto, which highlight the fresh, high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation. Guests rave about the "exceptional service" and the warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like dining with family. With its rich history and dedication to culinary excellence, Gargiulo’s is a cherished gem that continues to impress.

A photo of Michael's of Brooklyn restaurant

2. Michael's of Brooklyn

5.0

Exceptional(946)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Midwood

Booked 25 times today

Michael's of Brooklyn, nestled in the vibrant Midwood neighborhood, is a beacon of exceptional Seafood cuisine. For nearly sixty years, this family-owned gem has delighted patrons with its authentic Italian Seafood dishes, crafted from generations-old recipes. Guests rave about the "absolutely delicious" Chilean sea bass and the "mouthwatering" spaghetti with crab and shrimp, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and flavor. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, paired with a dedicated staff, ensures an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you're a local or visiting from afar, Michael's guarantees a Seafood feast that is "always extraordinary" and leaves diners eagerly awaiting their next visit.

3. Positano

4.8

Exceptional(643)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 19 times today

Positano is an Italian restaurant located in a quaint section of Bay Ridge. We offer Italian American cuisine with an emphasis on seafood, dry-aged steaks, homemade fresh pasta dishes and more! Perfect for families, a date, or an event! We are an upbeat locale with both indoor and outdoor dining offered.

A photo of Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay restaurant

4. Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay

4.8

Exceptional(10)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Sheepshead Bay

Booked 5 times today

Patrizia’s has been a family oriented concept for over 25 years. Each Patrizia's location is individually owned and operated to ensure that your dining experience at Patrizia’s is always great. As with Italian tradition, every single customer is treated like family. Each dish is prepared with fresh organic ingredients that uses family recipes dating back over 150 years. Aside from dining in, we also provide pick-up, delivery and catering for all occasions. Superb food, impeccable service, and a unique family atmosphere distinguishes Patrizia’s from any other restaurant and makes it a one of a kind experience. With locations in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Staten Island, Long Island (Hicksville, Massapequa, Commack & Hauppauge), Sheepshead Bay, Manhattan, Maspeth Queens, Red Bank, New Jersey & our always sunny locations in Fort Lauderdale, Deerfield Beach Florida & Aruba...Amazing family style dining is just around the corner.

A photo of Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria restaurant

5. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

4.9

Exceptional(75)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bensonhurst

Booked 3 times today

Il Colosseo Restaurant and Pizzeria in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is a standout destination for authentic Pizza Bar cuisine. Known for its intimate setting and warm, homey atmosphere, this local favorite enchants diners with its open kitchen, where a giant brick oven takes center stage. "Delicious authentic Italian food, great service and warm atmosphere," rave patrons, highlighting the mastery of their pizza offerings. The skilled kitchen staff crafts each pizza with precision, ensuring a perfect blend of flavors that truly captures the essence of Italy. With consistently great food and service, Il Colosseo is a must-visit for anyone craving a genuine Italian pizza experience.

6. Ponte Vecchio

4.7

Exceptional(172)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 6 times today

Ponte Vecchio in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, is a shining star for seafood aficionados. Celebrated for its authentic and delectable seafood dishes, the restaurant consistently impresses diners with its "spectacular" offerings. Patrons rave about the "best baked clams and fried calamari," while the "delicious crab sauce" has become a fan favorite. The Spaghetti Fruit del Mare and Soft Shell Crab are touted as must-tries, offering a taste of the sea that is both fresh and full of flavor. With impeccable service and a newly renovated elegant decor, Ponte Vecchio provides an inviting atmosphere that is perfect for memorable dining experiences.

A photo of Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge restaurant

7. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge

4.8

Exceptional(105)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 17 times today

Campania Coal Fired Pizza in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, is a standout destination for authentic Italian cuisine that delights the senses. Praised as "the best pizza in Brooklyn," the coal-fired method imparts a unique smoky flavor that sets it apart from traditional wood-fired pizzas. With a menu featuring signature creations like Margherita and Calabrese, and a build-your-own option, each pizza is a testament to quality and creativity. Guests rave about the "excellent atmosphere" and "attentive service," making you feel "like family." This neighborhood gem consistently delivers "absolutely delicious" meals, ensuring every visit is a memorable Italian culinary experience.

8. Cavatappi

4.9

Exceptional(66)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bensonhurst

Booked 1 time today

Welcome to Cavatappi Italian Restaurant - a family owned & operated establishment - located in the heart of Dyker Heights in Brooklyn. Our modern and cozy atmosphere is the perfect setting for a delicious meal. Our menu features a variety of classic Italian dishes, as well as some unique twists. Be sure to try our signature Kansas City pork chop, pan seared then baked to perfection and served with a side of parsnip apple sauce. Whether you're in the mood for pasta, seafood, or a hearty meat dish, we have something for everyone.We look forward to serving you at Cavatappi Italian Restaurant, where you can enjoy adelicious meal in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Buon apetito!

9. Don Cheech

4.7

Exceptional(271)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Shore Acres

Booked 9 times today

Don Cheech in Shore Acres, Staten Island, masterfully blends Italian and American cuisines, creating a unique dining experience that celebrates the authentic flavors of American classics with an elegant twist. Executive Chef Massimo Felici draws inspiration from NYC's Little Italy, crafting dishes that are "absolutely delicious" and "always flavorful and perfectly on point," as diners rave. The restaurant's charming atmosphere, complete with elegant tablecloth settings and a large bar, enhances its appeal. Patrons consistently praise the "fantastic service" and "wonderful experience," making Don Cheech a standout choice for anyone seeking an exceptional taste of American cuisine in a refined setting.

10. Greenhouse Cafe

4.8

Exceptional(252)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bay Ridge

The Greenhouse Cafe is located in middle of Bay Ridge in Brooklyn, New York. We have a full size bar and three dining rooms, which may also be used for catered affairs.

Best Italian Restaurants in Coney Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

88 restaurants available nearby

1. Gargiulo's Coney Island

2. Michael's of Brooklyn

3. Positano

4. Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay

5. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

6. Ponte Vecchio

7. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Bay Ridge

8. Cavatappi

9. Don Cheech

10. Greenhouse Cafe

See what locals rave about

Discover best Italian restaurants in Coney Island

Explore OpenTable