Best Italian Restaurants in North Tonawanda

Our recent dinner at Lucia’s on the Lake was excellent. We were seated right at our reservation time. The restaurant was tastefully decorated for Christmas. The menu was extensive with many great choices. The food and drinks were terrific. The wait staff was very friendly and attentive. Overall it was a memorable experience. Two thumbs up.

Everything is as advertised. All of the food was great. Homemade roasted peppers, homemade cannolis, even homemade dried chilies ... get the hint :-) . Everything super fresh in an awesome and unpretentious environment. The base sauces were not over-spiced or herbed (for me) and the portion sizes were generous. We had chicken parm, tagliatelle, roasted peppers, rapini chimichurri, lemon pistachio cannolis, and affogato and have more we want to get to based on this experience. I wish that it was closer to Halton ! We will be back

Enjoyed a family party for 11. Service was fantastic! Highly recommended for lunch, dinner. Try the meatball appetizer. Everyone was happy with the menu and enjoyed their choices. Will be back!

First time dining at this restaurant. Arrived early and was seated immediately on a very busy evening. Hostess was beyond friendly and pleasant. Difficult to see the menu based on lighting. Was brought an adjustable table lamp. That was an amazing first anywhere. Our server, Victoria, had a top notch command of the entire menu easily answering questions and making relevant recommendations. Amazingly professional and friendly young woman. Food was outstanding from cocktails, to apps, to entrees, to desserts. Everything perfectly prepared and brought to the table at the proper temperature. Lovely presentations. Service was impeccable throughout. Menu is pricey, but you absolutely get what you pay for. I will definitely recommend to others and return again.

Service was absolutely spectacular 🤩 Everythi g we ordered tasted great! Highly recommend to anyone, not just people in the casino.