Best Italian Restaurants in Rye

58 restaurants available nearby

1. 25 North

4.8

Exceptional(1655)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 24 times today

At 25 North in Mamaroneck, the essence of Contemporary Italian cuisine is celebrated with every dish served. Renowned for merging traditional Italian flavors with innovative culinary techniques, this restaurant offers an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about the "incredible gluten-free Chicken Parmigiano" and the "homemade pasta" that is simply "outrageous." The atmosphere is described as "trendy," and the service, led by standout staff like Miguel and Carmine, makes everyone "feel like family." With dishes like the Veal Valdostana and a must-try Godfather pasta, 25 North consistently wins over hearts. It's no wonder diners exclaim, "Food is fantastic and service is always top tier! Can’t wait to go back."

A photo of Averna Italian Steakhouse restaurant

2. Averna Italian Steakhouse

4.9

Exceptional(204)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Rye

Booked 15 times today

At Averna Italian Steakhouse in Rye, Westchester, diners rave about the exceptional seafood that complements their famous steaks, making it a standout destination for both steak and seafood lovers. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident, with reviews highlighting dishes like the "surf and turf" where the lobster is "perfectly cooked" and the "clams casino" described as delicious. A guest mentioned their first-time fish tasting experience with the salmon as "10/10," underscoring the seafood's freshness and superb preparation. Averna not only promises a luxurious dining experience but also delivers with seafood that is "over the top delicious," ensuring every visit is both memorable and delightful.

A photo of Augustine’s Salumeria restaurant

3. Augustine’s Salumeria

4.7

Exceptional(515)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 15 times today

At Augustine’s Salumeria in Mamaroneck, the brilliance of Contemporary Italian cuisine shines through each dish, crafted by the talented Chef Marc Taxiera. His philosophy of using the best local and seasonal ingredients to create minimally processed dishes has culminated in a menu that dazzles and delights. From the "squash blossoms filled with ricotta" to "linguini nero and lumache," each offering is a testament to authentic Italian flavors with a contemporary twist. Diners rave about the "perfectly cooked lamb chops" and the innovative "pea shoots salad with watermelon." The glowing reviews consistently highlight the exceptional service and ambiance, making Augustine’s Salumeria a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-tier dining experience in Westchester.

A photo of Alba's Restaurante - Port Chester restaurant

4. Alba's Restaurante - Port Chester

4.7

Exceptional(1290)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Port Chester

Booked 28 times today

Alba's Restaurante in Port Chester is a gem of Mediterranean cuisine, celebrated for its dedication to quality and authenticity. A family-run establishment for over three decades, Alba's is lauded for blending traditional Italian recipes with a modern twist, creating an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about the "exceptional service" and "delicious food," with standout dishes like the Parmesan crusted halibut and delectable tiramisu receiving particular praise. As one customer exclaims, it's the place where "food was exquisite" and "service was excellent." Whether it's a special occasion or a casual evening out, Alba's consistently delivers a luxurious culinary journey through the heart of Mediterranean flavors.

5. Polpo

4.6

Exceptional(1318)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Greenwich

Booked 33 times today

At Polpo in Greenwich, the allure of authentic Tuscan cuisine is vividly brought to life through its exceptional seafood offerings. Celebrated for over 20 years, Polpo has mastered the art of delivering fresh fish, exquisite lobster, and a renowned Polpo dish that has diners raving about its quality. A review exclaims, "the Bronzino perfectly cooked and deboned along with a Boulebais second Entree. The food was delicious!" This statement underscores the meticulous preparation and fresh ingredients that make their seafood dishes stand out. Whether it's a vibrant dining experience on their al fresco patio or a cozy indoor setting, Polpo promises a memorable seafood journey, making it a favorite spot in Greenwich for both locals and visitors.

6. Nonna Carola

4.8

Exceptional(559)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Mamaroneck

Booked 17 times today

Nonna Carola in Mamaroneck not only captures the essence of Italian cuisine but elevates it with a modern twist, focusing on fresh, local ingredients. Diners rave about the authenticity and quality of the dishes, describing them as "delicious every time with excellent quality food and authentic flavors" and consistently praising the superb service. The ambiance, described as both "calming and elegant," complements the exceptional meals, from the meticulously prepared salmon to the rich, flavorful pasta. A true gem in Mamaroneck, Nonna Carola stands out for its commitment to sustainability and memorable dining experiences, making it a must-visit for lovers of genuine Italian cuisine.

A photo of Meritage - Scarsdale restaurant

7. Meritage - Scarsdale

4.9

Exceptional(583)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Scarsdale

Booked 8 times today

Nestled in the heart of Scarsdale, Meritage Restaurant is a jewel in the crown of Italian cuisine, offering a sublime dining experience since 2004. Known for its "consistently great" Italian dishes, Meritage captures the essence of Italy with its carefully curated menu that features standout dishes like Rigatoni paired with a robust red wine, and the crowd-pleasing Bolognese that even the kids adore. Patrons rave about the "excellent food and impeccable service," highlighting the restaurant as a "hidden gem" with a "warm and hospitable ambiance." Whether it's the seabass or the short-rib ravioli, every dish promises a burst of authentic flavor, making Meritage a must-visit for anyone seeking a true taste of Italy in Scarsdale.

A photo of Patsy's Pizzeria of Harrison restaurant

8. Patsy's Pizzeria of Harrison

3.6

Very Good(60)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Harrison

Booked 1 time today

Patsy’s Pizzeria first opened its New York City location at 2287 1st Avenue in 1933, and quickly established itself as a family style, old-fashioned neighborhood restaurant. Patsy’s Pizzeria catered to the growing population of Italian immigrants who longed for the cuisine of their homeland in a casual family style atmosphere.

A photo of Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse restaurant

9. Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse

4.9

Exceptional(1456)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Larchmont

Booked 17 times today

Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse in Larchmont is a must-visit for steak enthusiasts. With a wealth of experience from high-end fine dining, Lenny’s brings the pinnacle of Steakhouse cuisine, featuring premium dry-aged cuts that are a testament to quality and taste. Patrons rave about the steaks, with one declaring the "porterhouse for 2 was perfectly done medium rare to rare. Prime matters!" Another highlighted their dining experience, “The ribeye is always excellent. Service once again perfect.” Lenny’s not only promises an unforgettable meal with its impeccable cuts but also ensures each guest feels valued and satisfied, making it a standout in the Steakhouse scene.

A photo of George Seafood & Steakhouse restaurant

10. George Seafood & Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(151)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Greenwich

Booked 2 times today

George Seafood & Steakhouse in Greenwich is a culinary gem that melds American cuisine with authentic Italian flair, creating an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about dishes like the "old school Carbonara" and "veal parmigiana," praising their freshness and authentic taste. Reviewers consistently highlight the exceptional service and the warm, welcoming atmosphere, making it a top choice for both relaxation and enjoyment. As one delighted diner put it, "The food was simply fantastic; everything was freshly prepared and flavorful." George's dedication to quality and authenticity makes it a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Italian cuisine in Greenwich.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Marshavip
New York City •12 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
We love this restaurant. The staff are gracious and the food is excellent.
More info
Nonna CarolaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Mamaroneck
•
4.8
A
Alicia
New York City •5 reviews
4.0
Dined 3 days ago
Our food was very good, nice selection of different choices. Our waitress was very pleasant, informative and helpful.
More info
Augustine’s SalumeriaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Mamaroneck
•
4.7
C
Christine
New York City •13 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 15, 2024
Great food & great service! Always a great experience. Can’t wait to go back!
More info
25 NorthPrice: Expensive• Italian• Mamaroneck
•
4.8
N
Nicole
New York State •1 review
5.0
Dined on Nov 15, 2024
My husband took me to Averna this week to celebrate my birthday. It was, by far, the best dining experience we've had since we moved to New York last year. The restaurant is upscale, but cozy and we felt at home here. From the greeting to the goodbye, the service was as amazing as the food. The entire staff made us feel like they really wanted to take care of us; the water glasses always full, attentive, but unobtrusive wait staff and bussers and the owner was a great host to everyone. Hubby had a beautiful ribeye and I had a gorgeous filet mignon; both cooked to medium rare perfection. We ordered maple bacon Brussels sprouts (addictively good), lobster mac & cheese ("OMG" good!) and grilled asparagus for the sides we shared. We started off with the light and delicious filet mignon carpaccio for our appetizer and for dessert we had coffee and split a caramel toffee cake. I'm not a big sweets person, but that cake was flipping amazing and the perfect way to end a birthday. I can't wait for our next visit. I've got my eye on the branzino!
More info
Averna Italian SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Steakhouse• Rye
•
4.9
B
Brucevip
New York City •11 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 13, 2024
Wow is all I can say. This place was amazing!!! Starting as soon as you walk in. The ambience is beautiful. The wait staff was amazing and the food was out of this world. I’m definitely going back!!! Highly recommended.
More info
Alba's Restaurante - Port ChesterPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Port Chester
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Rye

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

58 restaurants available nearby

1. 25 North

2. Averna Italian Steakhouse

3. Augustine’s Salumeria

4. Alba's Restaurante - Port Chester

5. Polpo

6. Nonna Carola

7. Meritage - Scarsdale

8. Patsy's Pizzeria of Harrison

9. Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse

10. George Seafood & Steakhouse

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable