Best Italian Restaurants in Sumner

A busy Saturday. Good thing we made a reservation. Last time we were here we had the same server Stacy. We just love her! She was very attentive, and her and the other servers were great! We were married here in 2018, and come here as much as we can. Thank you Mamas for being here!

We dined at Over the Moon for Valentines Day. From start to finish, the experience delivered everything we hoped for when we booked the reservation. We started w/ the clams, waldorf salad, and bisque. Clams: Smaller starter packed w/ flavor. Perfect way to start the evening. The fresh sourdough bread dipped in the clam broth was quite enjoyable. Waldorf salad: The beat/ parsnip puree in this salad was phenomenal and paired beautifully w/ the frisee, walnuts, and pickled fruits. Bisque: Light, refined, and filled w/ crab. Saved some sourdough for dipping and basically scraped the bowl clean. For mains, we had the duck breast and lobster mac and cheese. Duck: Perfectly cooked, crispy skin, unctuous cherry reduction. The side mashers and veg paired well. Lobster Mac: Very filling. Lobster chunks were apparent is nearly every single bite. To finish the meal, we enjoyed the lemon posset, which provided the perfect ending to an outstanding meal. Light, refreshing, and topped w/ a to-die-for strawberry sauce. Wish I had another right now. We always love our dining experiences at Over the Moon and this one was no exception. Needless to say, we'll be back sooner rather than later.

We have been going to Toscanos for around 20 years. The quality, service, ambience have always been 5 star. This is probably my overall favorite place for a exquisite dinner. Everything on the menu is top tier. Their steaks are as good or better than John Howie, Daniel's, etc. Service is top tier as well. In the 20 years I have known about and dined here, I have NEVER been disappointed.

Extremely happy with our meal at Marzano's. We had never been, but it was highly recommended by a friend. Will definitely be back more times to try more options. The service was impeccable, and the charm of the place was relaxing and enjoyable. Thank you for a special evening.

First time to Pink Door and it did not disappoint! Everything we had was fabulous, the service was great as was the atmosphere! I felt at times I was in the 50’s with the decor and music which was fun! They even had real candles! We will definitely be returning!