Best Italian Restaurants in Sheridan

Excellent food and service. The restaurant was all decked out in Christmas decor and lights. It was beautiful. We had a lovely dinner as a family.

The new chef is a game changer…entire staff is clearly excited about the change. Food was next level for Central Indiana.

Incredible authentic Italian food! Pasta was incredible, the sauce was fantastic, and the ambiance was cozy.

Rhonda and I had a delightful Christmas Eve dinner at Capri, and it exceeded all expectations. From the warm and friendly service provided by Gina and Trudy to the incredible homemade pasta from the Chef’s selection and Veal Parmigiana, every detail made the evening memorable. The Rubio San Polo 2022 red wine paired perfectly with our meals, and the crème brûlée and Italian coffee were the perfect finish. The atmosphere was inviting, authentic, and the conversations with Gina and Trudy made us feel like friends. If you’re looking for exceptional food, a great wine selection, and impeccable service, Capri is a must-visit. Highly recommended!

We’ve visited Italian House & Park several times a year, and every time it’s been a delightful experience. While the menu is full of tempting options, we always end up ordering the same dish—the Parmesan—and it never disappoints. It’s always cooked to perfection, with just the right balance of flavor and texture. This time, we were greeted warmly by Ashley, our bartender, who truly made the evening special with her excellent service and friendly demeanor. Although we had made a reservation for a table for four, we ended up staying at the bar, as we often do. The atmosphere is always welcoming and lively, and it’s become our favorite spot to enjoy a relaxed and delicious meal. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular like us, Italian House & Park never fails to deliver. Highly recommended!