Best Italian Restaurants in Simpson Bay

Roma does it again!!!! I am a student at the Medical School on this island, and having eaten at my fair share of restaurants on the French and Dutch side, I can honestly say Roma is my favorite restaurant. Marco, Matteo, and the rest of the crew are fantastic authentic Italian chefs that do Italian food as simply and authentically as possible while still having a nod to some Americanized favorites for those who have a special request (looking at you, chicken parmigiana lovers). Our server Yolaine was friendly, warm, and very attentive as always. I have been here several time as she was excellent as always. My family is visiting this week and Roma was my number one must visit, and as always, my family was beyond impressed. My fathers family still lives majority in Molise, so we have done a significant amount of traveling in Italy and our favorite Italian restaurant back home is run by a Michelin Starred chef, and honestly Roma stacks up with the best of them. The Pizza is 1000% the best on island, much more authentic with a real wood oven (vs Mamma’s), the 4 Roman pastas all use fantastic imported guanciale as they should, the wine selection is fantastic and very reasonably priced…. I could go on forever but do yourself a favor and make a reservation here and enjoy and Italian dinner you won’t forget!😊

Fantastic meal. Much better than I expected. Very good service. We ate here more than once on our stay. Everything is delicious.

Great location on Maho. We saw planes land while enjoying our meal. The wait staff was excellent, so friendly and attentive. The live singer was really good, we forgot she was singing live at times and thought it was recorded music. The wait for food wasn’t your normal “island time”, it was quicker. The food itself was good, but not the best we had on the island, but the staff and atmosphere makes up for it.

Always great food, good service and just a nice place all in all!

Absolutely a wonderful experience from the greeting, to the service, atmosphere (decor) and food. Took a chance going here and was so pleasantly surprised. Drinks were reasonably priced and delicious. Jai was our server and she was wonderful. I had Caesar salad which was a little pricey but then it came and it was huge. My eggplant Parmesan appetizer was big enough for dinner. Highly recommend.