Best Italian Restaurants in Vail

We went for the first time last night for the Valentines tasting menu and it was great! The place is very sophisticated but not intimidating. The food and service were both right on point. We enjoyed everything on the tasting menu. The beef course was cooked to perfection. The potato that came with it was a bit dry and bland, but that would be the only thing that was not wonderful about the entire meal we find it to be a welcome addition to the valley’s food scene, and can’t wait to go back.

The food and service is top notch. Our table was not quite ready but there was space at the bar. the bartender made the drinks as expected but also provided guidance on the wines. Once seated the service was equally good. The plates were described well. The waiter offered guidance. The portions are LARGE. The food is prepared expertly. The temperature is appropriate. The flavors are excellent. As one would expect, the truffle menu is sublime. The wine choices are excellent. The wine prices are in line with what one expects in Vail. No complaints whatsoever.

We have been coming to Beaver Creek for over 20 years. Fattoria has become one of our favorite dining experiences. We dine here both winter and summer trips. The food and wine menu are exceptional! The Fattoria Team remembers our names and always provides friendly service. Our server Josh was great. Always nice to see Steve who was host for the evening. Cheers!

Ti Amo has been a presence in the Vail Valley dining scene for about 30 years and deserves its longevity. It has been a favorite dining spot for our family for all of that time. We have been making visits to the area to ski for over 50 years. The Italian menu is remarkably robust and contains many excellent choices, so many that there should be something for everyone to enjoy in any dining party. Portions are generous. Nobody will go home hungry! My personal favorites are the Bruschetta al Prosciutto, the Messicani di Vitello, and the chocolate Tartuffo or the Profiteroles for dessert, but I emphasize again that the menu choices are many and we have never had a bad experience here. The atmosphere is charming and cozy. Service is superb. They added clear partitions between the tables, probably in response to the pandemic. They preserve visibility, are designed to fit in with the decor, and have the added advantage of some noise reduction. Ti Amo opened a sister restaurant in Eagle, about 24 miles from Vail. Similar menu. It is in a separate building adjacent to I-70 and a shopping center. Ti Amo will alway be a family tradition for us. It remains very popular with both locals and visitors so reserve well in advance, especially during the ski season. Highest recommendation. Well worth the short drive from Vail or Beaver Creek.

The food was amazing and the service was fabulous. All the staff were very welcoming, bright and joyous . It was a wonderful evening.