Best Sicilian Restaurants in Rutherford

40 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Bareli's Restaurant - Secaucus restaurant

1. Bareli's Restaurant - Secaucus

4.9

Exceptional(1004)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Secaucus

Booked 13 times today

Bareli's Restaurant in Secaucus is a top-tier destination for seafood aficionados. Known for its "abundance of seafood" and expertly crafted dishes, Bareli's promises an authentic and high-quality dining experience. The seafood salad, praised for its plentiful seafood and light vinaigrette, exemplifies the restaurant's commitment to freshness and flavor. Diners rave about the "Scungili salad" special, describing it as "excellent" and showcasing the culinary prowess of the kitchen. Whether it's succulent shrimp or the signature Angry Lobster, each dish is an ode to the ocean, prepared with the finest ingredients and a touch of Italian flair.

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

2. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(30085)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Theater District

Booked 382 times today

Carmine's - 44th Street in NYC's vibrant Theater District is a gem for Contemporary Italian cuisine that truly stands out. The restaurant's dedication to delivering generous family-style portions echoes the warmth of an Italian American wedding feast, making every visit feel like a "Sunday afternoon at Grandma's." With a menu brimming with made-to-order pasta, succulent seafood, and exquisite homemade desserts, diners are in for a treat. The glowing reviews speak volumes with remarks like "food was truly amazing" and "service was fast and attentive." Carmine's is not just a meal; it's a delightful culinary experience worth savoring.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Estiatorio restaurant

3. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

4.7

Exceptional(1665)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 54 times today

Nestled in the vibrant SoHo neighborhood of New York, Piccola Cucina Estiatorio is a culinary gem that brings the authentic flavors of Sicilian and Greek cuisine to life. Praised for its "super flavorful and fresh" dishes, this Mediterranean haven offers an array of delectable options that promise to delight the palate. Diners rave about the "high quality" of food, highlighting the delicious pastas and delightful appetizers. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service create a dining experience akin to a "family dinner," making patrons feel right at home. For those seeking a genuine taste of the Mediterranean, Piccola Cucina Estiatorio is a must-visit destination.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Uptown restaurant

4. Piccola Cucina Uptown

4.8

Exceptional(2189)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Upper East Side

Booked 94 times today

Piccola Cucina Uptown, nestled in the vibrant Upper East Side of New York, offers a superb journey into Contemporary Italian cuisine. This charming gem exudes warmth and authenticity, setting the stage for an unparalleled dining experience. Guests rave about its "impeccable service" and the "incredible" freshness and flavor of their dishes, particularly the handmade pastas and Sicilian specialties. The restaurant's attention to detail is evident, from the expertly crafted tiramisu to the delightful table-side presentations. As one reviewer enthusiastically shared, "It's a gem I’ll definitely return to!" Whether for a cozy dinner or lively gathering, Piccola Cucina Uptown promises an unforgettable culinary adventure.

A photo of Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St. restaurant

5. Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.

4.7

Exceptional(2503)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • SoHo

Booked 24 times today

Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St. in SoHo, New York, offers an authentic Mediterranean dining experience that truly stands out. The restaurant's dedication to serving "the real taste of Sicily" is evident in every dish, with fresh, home-cooked flavors that transport diners straight to Italy. Patrons rave about the "amazing food and service," highlighting dishes like the Wild Boar Tagliatelle and the tableside-made Tiramisu as "must-try" items. The cozy, energetic atmosphere coupled with a "friendly staff" ensures a delightful dining experience. This hidden gem, with its genuine Sicilian cuisine, is a must-visit for anyone craving an unforgettable Mediterranean meal.

6. Il Melograno

4.8

Exceptional(1303)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 4 times today

Il Melograno, nestled in Hell's Kitchen, is a beacon of authentic Sicilian cuisine, capturing the essence of Southern Italy's culinary traditions. Owners Lino and Gregory bring a slice of Sicily to New York City, honoring the cherished recipes of their grandmothers. Diners rave about the "handcrafted pastas" and "authentic Sicilian appetizers" that consistently exceed expectations. The cozy ambiance and attentive service create a warm, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for pre-theater dining or a special night out. Il Melograno is praised as a "neighborhood gem" with dishes that are "delicious, authentically Italian, and fresh," making it a must-visit for lovers of genuine Sicilian fare.

A photo of Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC restaurant

7. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(8554)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Upper West Side

Booked 69 times today

Carmine's - 91st Street in NYC is a beacon of Contemporary Italian excellence, offering an authentic dining experience reminiscent of "Sunday at Grandma's house." Located in the vibrant Upper West Side, this family-style restaurant serves up generous portions of Southern Italian classics that are perfect for sharing. Diners rave about the "fantastic food," with dishes like manicotti and bolognese being standout favorites. The welcoming atmosphere and "impeccable service" contribute to its charm, making every meal feel like a festive occasion. Whether you're celebrating a special event or enjoying a casual meal, Carmine's promises a "core memory experience" with every visit!

8. Cafe Fiorello

4.7

Exceptional(10382)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Lincoln Square

Booked 116 times today

Cafe Fiorello in Lincoln Square, New York, offers an exceptional Vegetarian/Vegan dining experience that has captivated locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its sprawling antipasto bar, the restaurant showcases an impressive variety of beautifully prepared vegetables that promise to delight even the most discerning palates. Guests rave about the "luscious options" available, making it a standout choice for those seeking high-quality plant-based cuisine. The warm, inviting ambiance combined with a dedicated staff that "makes you feel very special" adds to the overall charm. Whether you're a lifelong vegetarian or simply exploring, Cafe Fiorello offers a memorable culinary journey that is not to be missed.

9. Osteria Nonnino

4.6

Exceptional(252)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • West Village

Booked 53 times today

Osteria Nonnino in West Village, New York, offers an exquisite Contemporary Italian dining experience that marries the rich culinary traditions of northern and southern Italy. This family-owned gem, helmed by Chef Tony Kavaja, delights guests with a menu that is both innovative and authentic. "Fresh ingredients, tasty food, it was definitely a great experience," rave diners, applauding the impeccable service and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant's charming outdoor area provides a serene escape, making every visit feel like a stroll through Italy. With dishes prepared tableside and a menu that leaves guests spoiled for choice, Osteria Nonnino "truly is a taste of Italy."

10. Little Owl

4.8

Exceptional(4375)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • West Village

Booked 79 times today

Nestled in the charming West Village, Little Owl is a delightful gem that consistently delivers exceptional American cuisine with a Mediterranean twist. Celebrated for its "amazing food" and "warm and cozy ambiance," this beloved spot has been a favorite among New Yorkers since 2006. Diners rave about the tender pork chop and a variety of expertly crafted fish dishes that keep them coming back for more. The "attentive and welcoming" staff create a homey atmosphere that makes every visit feel special. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Little Owl is a must-visit for an authentic and unforgettable American dining experience.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

M
Maureen
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
My daughter and I shared a delicious beet salad and a perfectly prepared pork chop. The bread appetizer with chopped sun-dried tomatoes was amazing too. Service was attentive but not hovering. A lovely meal.
More info
Il MelogranoPrice: Moderate• Italian• Hell's Kitchen
•
4.8
M
Mark
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 10, 2025
Absolutely amazing food. Very quick and polite service. Very impressed.
More info
Bocca Di Bacco (Theatre District - 45th St.)Price: Moderate• Italian• Theater District
•
4.4
C
Cathy
New York City •17 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 9, 2025
We love Osteria Nonnino! Always cozy and welcoming (Vita), delicious food, and amazing wait staff (Enzo last night). We’ll be back again and again!
More info
Osteria NonninoPrice: Expensive• Italian• West Village
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Rutherford

Sicilian

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Rutherford

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

40 restaurants available nearby

1. Bareli's Restaurant - Secaucus

2. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

3. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio

4. Piccola Cucina Uptown

5. Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.

6. Il Melograno

7. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

8. Cafe Fiorello

9. Osteria Nonnino

10. Little Owl

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable