5 Best Steak Restaurants In Sag Harbor

5 restaurants available nearby

1. Old Stove Pub

4.5

Price: Expensive

• Steak • Bridgehampton

Old Stove Pub in Bridgehampton is a celebrated Hamptons classic, offering an exquisite Steakhouse experience that keeps diners coming back since its transformation in 1969. Rejuvenated with extensive restorations, this charming establishment "stands out for its steaks cooked to perfection," as one delighted diner raved. The warmth of a wood-burning fireplace and attentive service create a cozy, inviting atmosphere that feels like home. Guests appreciate the personal touch from the owners, making every visit memorable. Whether dining in their spacious outdoor tent or inside, Old Stove Pub delivers a delectable and authentic Steakhouse experience that is truly unparalleled in the Hamptons.

2. M.J. Dowling's

4.5

Awesome(264)

Price: Moderate

• Steak • Sag Harbor

Booked 3 times today

MJ Dowling’s Steakhouse and Tavern in the heart of Sag Harbor offers an unforgettable Steakhouse dining experience that is both authentic and inviting. This family-owned gem is praised for its "marinated hanger steak cooked to perfection," making it a must-try for steak enthusiasts. The comfortable and "relaxing environment" complements the consistently excellent service and delicious food, ensuring every visit is memorable. Diners rave about the "fabulous beef sliders" and are delighted by the nightly specials that offer a taste of their diverse menu at incredible value. MJ Dowling’s truly stands out as a neighborhood favorite, perfect for any occasion.

A photo of The Palm East Hampton restaurant

3. The Palm East Hampton

4.6

Exceptional(1055)

Price: Very Expensive

• Steak • East Hampton

Booked 21 times today

The Palm East Hampton, nestled inside the charming Huntting Inn, offers a seafood cuisine that truly delights the senses. Diners rave about the "amazing lobster" and "delicious fish," praising the restaurant for its exceptional quality and fresh flavors. Guests consistently highlight the "fantastic" service and welcoming atmosphere, noting that every visit is a memorable experience. The Palm's lobster dinner for two is particularly popular, offering "great food and great value" in a stunning setting. As a staple in East Hampton, The Palm's commitment to authentic and fresh seafood makes it a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.

A photo of The Waterlot - Fairmont Southampton restaurant

4. The Waterlot - Fairmont Southampton

new

4.8

Exceptional(777)

Price: Very Expensive

• Steak • Southampton

Booked 46 times today

The Waterlot, Bermuda's iconic dining destination, re-opened its doors on Wednesday, December 4th. Executive Chef Hamish Lindsay brings global culinary expertise with a focus on flavors that embody the island’s spirit—think local ingredients reimagined in dishes like the Bermuda Chowder Tortellini and the signature Surf & Turf featuring vanilla-poached Bermuda lobster. Maître D' Barry Cohen, returning with a passion for warm, memorable service, has curated an atmosphere where every visit feels like a celebration, whether a milestone or an everyday escape.The Waterlot now invites guests to revel in life's simple joys as well as grand occasions. With a welcoming ambiance, this is a place to gather, connect, and savor Bermuda’s culinary heritage. Elegance here feels relaxed, encouraging you to unwind, connect, and experience the heart of Bermuda with every bite and shared moment.

A photo of Claudio's Tavern & Grill restaurant

5. Claudio's Tavern & Grill

4.2

Awesome(341)

Price: Expensive

• Steak • Greenport

Claudio's Tavern & Grill in Greenport, New York, is a beacon of authentic American cuisine, seamlessly blending tradition with quality. Known for its rich maritime history, this establishment serves up "the best Ribeye in town" alongside delightful seasonal fare such as local Day Boat Scallops. Diners rave about the "exquisite brunch" and "fantastic fish and chips," capturing the true essence of American coastal dining. The attentive service, with standout waitstaff like Cassandra and Brett, ensures a memorable dining experience. With its charming seaside ambiance, Claudio’s is not just a meal, but a tradition cherished by locals and visitors alike.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Steak Restaurants in Sag Harbor

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility