Best Authentic Restaurants in Brewster

We love the food there. The service was outstanding

Good food and great attentive service. Everything was served professionally and the waiters never rushed us. When my son's filet was overcooked they fired a new one immediately and it was perfect! Not many restaurants are open on Thanksgiving and we appreciate the price fixe menu options, wine and service.

The food was exceptional, and the wait staff was abundant, outrageously attentive, and met our every need. We were there for Thanksgiving with a pre-fix menu, and the chef was still happy to accommodate our special requests. The atmosphere has a small restaurant feel with a lovely open bar area and the TV volume off. 5-star experience inside Costello's. There was one significant problem. If you do not make it into one of the 7 or 8 parking spots in the garage or need handicapped access, the parking is horrendous, absolutely awful. Truly, you must back down a very steep incline with cars closely parked on either side with a telephone pole and sign at the bottom of the hill - I am serious! To avoid both of those, which, in the rain and darkness, I did not, you must back onto the sidewalk, then drive forward on the sidewalk and over the curb to merge with traffic. Because of the dangerous parking, I will sadly never return to enjoy this awesome food.

It was quiet in a good way for a crowded restaurant! The food was delicious and the service was excellent

Overly generous portions, extensive menu and extremely fairly priced. Service is top notch, wait staff is accomodating and patient. Place is immaculate, you can eat off the floors. Food was incredibly tasteful, absolute perfection from top to bottom. Would HIGHLY recommend!!!