Best Authentic Restaurants in Mullet Bay

10 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana restaurant

1. Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana

4.8

Exceptional(296)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

Booked 20 times today

All roads lead to Roma, your favorite new Italian dining experience!At Roma, we believe that the most important thing about great food is the ingredients. That's why we use only the freshest, highest-quality products from Italy and from around the world.Our chef Matteo was born and raised in Rome, and he knows how to make authentic Italian food that will knock your socks off. When you come here for dinner, either in our main dining room or in our garden "Al Fresco" you'll feel like you're back in Italy—but with a modern twist. We're happy to welcome you in our cozy yet classy atmosphere for an unforgettable dining experience.

2. La Patrona

4.2

Awesome(44)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Simpson Bay

Booked 3 times today

We use authentic Mexican ingredients. From the hand-made tortilla to the chiles in nogada. Also we can cook for you on the edge of your table to wrap the magic that generates this type of cuisine.We have exclusive tequilas and mezcales that can be enjoyed in the authentic Mexican way guided by our hosts and get to know the most intimate secrets of mezcal and tequila. We will also have the most exclusive cocktails menu where you can enjoy mixtures developed by our expert mixologists.La Patrona will also feature "The Patrona’s Table", an exclusive place where you can experience the true secrets of ancient dishes that will fill you with new flavors and a great culinary experience.We open for breakfast, lunch and dinner from 7 a.m. to 11 p.m. everyday.

A photo of La Rosa Italian Restaurant restaurant

3. La Rosa Italian Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(13)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Simpson Bay

Booked 2 times today

Nestled in the far corner of the Maho Resort complex, La Rosa is a familiar haunt for Locals and visitors-in the-know.Consistent top-quality Italian food with a Caribbean flair, served by a prompt, friendly staff in an attractive atmosphere has kept them coming back for Conch au gratin, Spicy Fisherman's Soup, Ossobuco, Veal Milanese, fine wines, fresh seafood, hand-cut steaks and the daily chef specials.Dine outside on our expanded veranda or inside air-conditioned. Free WiFi.

4. Topper's

4.4

Awesome(18)

Price: Moderate

• International • Cole Bay

Booked 2 times today

This famed eatery, voted # 1 international restaurant, is located directly on the water serving guests for more than 18 yrs. The extensive menu emphasizes locally caught lobster, fresh salads, pasta, and Certified Angus Beef cooked to perfection. Serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy daily happy-hour specials and the Thursday night Broadway dance show. The bar is a local hangout well known for nightly Karaoke, where guests stay to sing and dance the night away. This family-owned restaurant is set in a gorgeous landmark waterfront location that stunningly accommodates the restaurant, rhum distillery, bar, authentic Italian gelateria, and gift shop. Topper’s Rhum, St. Maarten’s official rum, is winner of over thirty international medals and holds the prestigious title of USA Today’s Best Caribbean Rum Distillery. Enjoy a tour or stop by for tasting and shopping. Experience this extraordinary, fun, and unforgettable destination!

5. Ocean 82

4.9

Exceptional(407)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary French • Grand Case

Booked 18 times today

Blending simplicity with chic design, Ocean 82 is a French restaurant mixed with tastes of the sea. Located on the water, flavors designed by Chef Franck Vuillemin will entice you to return again and again.

6. Bistrot Caraïbes

4.8

Exceptional(590)

Price: Expensive

• French • Grand Case

Booked 10 times today

Bistrot Caraibes has been Created on Saint-Martin Island in 1994, by the two Brothers, Thibault and Amaury Mezière.The restaurant features a Lovely setting where returning clientele keep rating the Bistrot Caraibes as being one of the top 5 establishments on the Island of Saint-Martin / Sint-Maarten.The Relaxing, Romantic, and Casual Atmosphere will be a Great Dining Experience during your next vacation in Saint-MartinBistrot Caraibes is a 50 Seat Restaurant. We do have the Facilities to wait on large Parties,up to 50.

7. Maison Mère

4.6

Exceptional(106)

Price: Expensive

• French • Marigot

Booked 15 times today

Faire d'un dîner, un moment d'exception, de goût et de convivialité où l'on se sent aussi bien qu'à la maison... Voici la promesse de Maison Mère, restaurant français avec influence créole, à Saint-Martin.Nous garantissons des produits de première qualité, que nous travaillons avec passion et amour, de l'entrée au dessert. Notre équipe s'occupe de vous avec intérêt, attention et professionnalisme. Classiques ou inventifs, nos cocktails vous séduiront sans nul doute !

A photo of C Level – Aurora Anguilla Resort restaurant

8. C Level – Aurora Anguilla Resort

4.7

Exceptional(23)

Price: Moderate

• Caribbean • Anguilla

We are situated on the grounds of the beautiful Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club. We welcome all guests from other resorts and hotels on the island as well as the general public.A refined destination for the freshest seafood on the island. Enjoy the catch of the day seasoned with authentic Anguillian flavors or unwind from a day spent exploring with creative cocktails by the sea. A deep dive into Anguillian culture and Caribbean flavors where island-inspired spices and fresh-caught seafood come together in harmony to celebrate the abundance of the sea. Enjoy tropical cocktails and small plates with your feet in the Rendezvous sand while catching sun rays. An abundance of beauty and flavor is found here.For large bookings please contact our hotel concierge at concierge@auroraanguilla.com.

A photo of Tokyo Bay - Aurora Anguilla Resort restaurant

9. Tokyo Bay - Aurora Anguilla Resort

4.5

Awesome(67)

Price: Moderate

• Japanese • Anguilla

Booked 2 times today

We are situated on the grounds of the beautiful Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club. We welcome all guests from other resorts and hotels on the island as well as the general public.Revel in reimagined modern Japanese cuisine amid an inspired tropical setting. Acclaimed Executive Chef Joe Richardson has developed a menu specializing in traditional techniques and interactive family-style plates. With exquisite seafood curated from destinations around the world, our dishes are further elevated by ingredients grown in Aurora Anguilla’s on-property garden.For large bookings please contact our hotel concierge at concierge@auroraanguilla.com.

10. Half Shell

new

5.0

Exceptional(0)

Price: Very Expensive

• Mexican • Anguilla

Booked 2 times today

Discover the vibrant flavors of coastal Mexico at HalfShell, a restaurant that blends authentic culinary traditions with a lively and colorful atmosphere. Located within the Four Seasons, HalfShell offers a unique “food theater” experience, where every detail—from the bold dishes to the festive ambiance—immerses guests in Mexican culture. Enjoy freshly prepared tostadas paired with bold, flavorful salsas that celebrate the rich influence of corn in Mexican cuisine. Indulge in our signature cocktails, crafted to surprise and delight: El Teporocho, El Brebaje, y La Michelada con Camarón.Enjoy freshly prepared tostadas paired with bold, flavorful salsas that celebrate the rich influence of corn in Mexican cuisine. Our setting reflects the joy and folklore of Mexico, with vibrant table décor, colorful textiles, and elements inspired by traditional folk art. This creates a sociable and buzzing atmosphere perfect for dinner or celebrations.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

L
Ludovica
Rome •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Un piccolo angolo d’Italia a St Maarten! Chef Matteo truly puts his whole heart and soul in his truly authentic Italian cooking and so does the pizzaiolo Cristian. We enjoyed every single minute from the appetizers to dessert. Number 1 Italian restaurant on the island FOR SURE! Parola di Italiana, si mangia come a casa! Will definitely be back!
More info
Roma Restaurant Cucina ItalianaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Simpson Bay
•
4.8
J
Jeanne
Philadelphia County •9 reviews
4.0
Dined on Dec 13, 2024
Service was great and we all enjoyed our meals. Karaoke was a fun addition.
More info
Topper'sPrice: Moderate• International• Cole Bay
•
4.4
J
James
New York City •8 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 10, 2024
Absolutely incredible experience. The staff was first class. The menu gives options for everyone and the food was as good as it gets. Elite restaurant
More info
Ocean 82Price: Very Expensive• Contemporary French• Grand Case
•
4.9
K
Kay
Tahoe / Reno Area •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 4, 2024
Always great food, good service and just a nice place all in all!
More info
La Rosa Italian RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Italian• Simpson Bay
•
4.6
A
Ann
Montreal / Quebec •5 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 1, 2024
We really enjoyed the experience and we were seated by the beach ! . Food was good and authentic and service was outstanding !
More info
La PatronaPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Simpson Bay
•
4.2

Explore OpenTable

Mullet Bay

Best Authentic Restaurants in Mullet Bay

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Roma Restaurant Cucina Italiana

2. La Patrona

3. La Rosa Italian Restaurant

4. Topper's

5. Ocean 82

6. Bistrot Caraïbes

7. Maison Mère

8. C Level – Aurora Anguilla Resort

9. Tokyo Bay - Aurora Anguilla Resort

10. Half Shell

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable