Best Casual Restaurants in Middletown

We love Cozy's - brunch, lunch and dinner. My husband was slightly disappointed at first that we were going for brunch because his most favorite thing on their menu is "crab in a cup". And they don't offer that at brunch. :-) However, we had a wonderful meal in spite of that. I had the short rib skillet (short rib over potato hash with scrambled eggs on top and a biscuit on the side). He had the Down Home breakfast with the grilled andouille sausage. We really enjoyed both though he wished the waffles were larger - they were described as "mini", but they were more like "baby". Overall always great service and atmosphere - one of our "go to" places.

Our server was amazing! She was able to assist with questions we had and was very proactive in keeping drinks filled and anticipating anything we needed. She was very friendly and able to make recommendations. It is rare when dining out to find a server who was on top of things as much as this server was. Food was great, service was fast and we thoroughly enjoyed our time celebrating our son's 25th birthday

This little gem exceeded my expectations. On a cold winter's day, the atmosphere was comforting. The food was sooo very good, and plenty of healthy options (more than I had expected). ITheir homemade French Onion soup was so rich! And even a simple salad very well executed. The old building is beautiful, with original woodwork and tasteful color palette. Our server was spot-on, although it wasn't a crowded day. All of this for what I consider a very low price! I definitely plan to come back.

Food was great, service was great-Ben was our server and he did all he could to see that we had a good experience. Our food arrived quickly and was hot. We are wanting to go again soon and for Valentine’s Day 2025.

good time considering the circumstances. its a tradition!