Best Cozy Restaurants in Millersville

My wife and I dinned at 401 Prime on 2/15/2025 for a valentine’s date night. Steven was our server and I must say, the best experience we ever had. This was our first date night since moving to Lancaster from California and Steven made it a night to remember. Ask for Steven!!!

Typically it’s difficult for a restaurant to pull everything off perfectly.. from the moment you enter the building to the time you leave.. but The Belvie Inn did just that! The restaurant is beautiful, the service was excellent, our dishes were always cleared promptly & the courses were perfectly spaced that we didn’t feel rushed at any point or that we were waiting. Also- most importantly the food was outstanding. We will definitely return many times! Perfect spot for your romantic nights out!

My Fiance and I went to Plough for Valentine’s day. The food was out of the world. The waiter, L, was amazing as well and took good care of us, always making sure our waters were full and explaining the menu items to us! For a valentine’s day meal we were surprised with a rose at the end which added a super special touch to the evening. 10/10, 5 stars, would highly recommend. If I could give more stars I would!!!

We had a lovely Valentine’s Day experience in a quiet section of our favorite restaurant. Our server was charming, efficient, and helpful. Our food was delicious and my Frosted Fig refreshment was outstanding. From appetizers to desserts we were delighted with our dining experience.

We have visited the Exchange many times and have never been disappointed. The food (pizza) was delicious and the service staff were the best. This is a great place to take friends for a unique experience.