Best Cozy Restaurants in Plumsteadville

We had a reservation and were promptly seated when we arrived. Our server was very attentive and the food arrived at a very timely manner. Turkey dinner was wonderful and the chicken pot pie was very tasty. I would definitely visit again.

Delicious food, attractive setting and good service.

The food was fabulous. A true culinary treat. We chose a la carte and each of the four courses were over the top delicious. Our compliments to Chef Greg. Our wait person Brad's knowledge about each dish made the experience more enjoyable. Kudos to all the staff a Barley Sheaf Farm for a lovely meal.

We were there for an early Sunday supper. It was a surprise to get stone crab claw cocktail. Both my chicken croquette and my husband’s prime rib, princess cut were very, very delicious. The croquettes taste like how they would cook in Japan. The prime rib was quality meat and cooked just right. We also enjoyed the apricot walnut bread pudding. Our server, Airyn was very very knowledgeable about the dishes and gave us a thorough description of everything. The food was served fast enough surprisingly in a very busy restaurant. Overall, we were very happy.

The food is always excellent, with innovative twists. The service was great, the staff is always pleasant, and you're never rushed. Brunch today, but lunch, dinner, or just drinks, a trip to The Water Wheel is NEVER a disappointment!