Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Cozy Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

7 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Claudio's Tavern & Grill restaurant
1. Claudio's Tavern & Grill
3.9
Excellent(337)
Price: Expensive
• Seafood • Greenport
Booked 2 times today
Claudio's Tavern & Grill is a cozy place as noted in multiple reviews. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and customers love the friendly staff. It's also described as a great spot for a dinner with beautiful views, which adds to the cozy ambiance.
A photo of The North Fork Table & Inn restaurant
2. The North Fork Table & Inn
4.6
Exceptional(2423)
Price: Very Expensive
• Contemporary American • Southold
North Fork Table is an East End institution. Set in a historic countryside home, the restaurant celebrates the bounty of Long Island’s farms, vineyards & waterways with menus by restaurateur & chef John Fraser. The restaurant’s menu focus is seasonally inspired featuring locally grown biodynamic and organic produce, the freshest seafood from the pristine Peconic Bay and Long Island Sound and award-winning North Fork duck and beef. Increasingly distinguished and awarded Long Island wines are highlighted on the wine list, as well as their national and international counterparts.
A photo of Vine Street Cafe restaurant
3. Vine Street Cafe
4.7
Exceptional(1844)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Shelter Island
Booked 9 times today
Chef/Owners Lisa & Terry Harwood opened Vine Street Cafe in 2003. Located on South Ferry Road, just 1.5 miles from the South Ferry. Chef Terry works with area farmers, fishermen & vineyards and features their natural bounty on his seasonal menus. We make everything in house and Lisa's desserts, ice creams and fruit crisps are no exception. Recently, we opened a small market behind the restaurant. This is where you pick up take-out orders while stocking your home pantry. Specialty catering is available along with ready fresh meals such as meatballs, chicken salad, bread, smoked ribs, BBQ Sauce and a selection of artisan pastas. Reservations are highly recommended year round.
A photo of Olive Branch Cafe restaurant
4. Olive Branch Cafe
4.6
Exceptional(194)
Price: Expensive
• Mediterranean • Greenport
Turkish Restaurant offering numerous Mediterranean menu items. Unwind in our comfortable atmosphere while sipping of a cup of coffer or tea. Join us for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner!
A photo of Sophie's Rest. restaurant
5. Sophie's Rest.
4.6
Exceptional(49)
Price: Moderate
• American • Southold
Booked 4 times today
We refuse to compromise on quality in our restaurant. That's why we source our fresh ingredients from local farms and fish markets. Everything from in house hand cut steaks to our daily "catch of the day." No matter what time of year, you can be sure you're eating the best of the season.Special Nights: Prime Rib Tuesday Includes: Caesar salad- Generous cut of Prime Rib with chef's choice potato and vegetable $37Please call in advance (by the Monday night before) for Prime Rib Tuesday reservations at 631-765-5700
A photo of The Restaurant at Baron's Cove restaurant
6. The Restaurant at Baron's Cove
4.0
Excellent(61)
Price: Expensive
• American • Sag Harbor
Booked 4 times today
The restaurant at Baron’s Cove features classic, all-American cuisine with a separate lounge and bar area, welcoming hotel guests as well as local visitors. In 2023 & 2024 the restaurant was awarded with the "Award of Excellence" by Wine Spectator.While dining with us enjoy panoramic views from a table on the deck! The menu offers beloved, classic American fare, including succulent fish and buttery lobster rolls. All dishes are prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. With its second-floor location, the dining room offers stunning views of the harbor.For more intimate gatherings, we offer The Map Room -also located on the second floor- which can be reserved for Private events of upto 20 guests. We look forward to welcoming you to Baron's Cove!
A photo of K Pasa restaurant
7. K Pasa
new
4.5
Awesome(128)
Price: Moderate
• Tapas / Small Plates • Sag Harbor
We love great tacos. Not the traditional fried shells, but inventive, healthy and delicious tacos that you will want to eat every day. K Pasa means neighborhood, local, in both our food and style. We are right around the corner and we know where you like to sit and what you like to eat. Tacos and tequila taste even better with a Sag Harbor water view.K Pasa is an American taqueria created by chefs and restaurateurs who live and work here. Inspired by the all-day après beach lifestyle of the East End, Laguna Beach, and Malibu. Our tacos (tequila bar and rosés) are for sharing. We’re gluten-free & vegan-friendly and frequented by sailors, pirates, and fun-seekers. K Pasa is about keeping the local summer vibe going all year round.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you

Discover best cozy restaurants in Shelter Island

Discover the charming dining scene in Shelter Island, Suffolk, where cozy restaurants invite you to indulge in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Nestled in this idyllic New York location, each eatery brings its unique blend of comfort and culinary delight, perfect for those seeking a relaxed meal in a snug setting. From beautifully wrapped porches to intimate interiors, the keyword 'cozy' truly captures the essence of dining here. These establishments pride themselves on offering a personal touch, with meticulously crafted menus that highlight local flavors and ingredients. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner spot or a place to gather with friends, Shelter Island’s cozy restaurants provide the perfect backdrop. Enjoy the serene environment and exceptional service that make each dining experience here not just a meal, but a memorable event. This haven of cozy dining is ideal for food lovers and travelers alike, looking to savor moments as well as meals.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo