Best Date Night Restaurants in Paia

We would absolutely recommend the Banyan Tree! The food, although pricey, was totally worth it! The vegetables were locally sourced, fresh and amazing!! The meat and fish were cooked to perfection! Service was excellent!

Great service, food not as good as I remember it to be

We had the absolute pleasure of being served by Jay during our visit at the bar, and he is truly the best bartender we've ever encountered! From the moment we sat down, Jay’s warm and welcoming energy made us feel right at home. He has an incredible knack for reading his guests and crafting personalized cocktails that not only taste amazing but are beautifully presented. Jay’s knowledge of mixology is unmatched. He didn’t just make drinks—he created an experience. Beyond his talent, Jay has a genuine personality that makes him stand out. His quick wit, engaging stories, and effortless professionalism turned our evening into something truly special to celebrate our 10 year anniversary. It’s clear that he takes great pride in his craft, and it shows in every detail. If you're lucky enough to be served by Jay, you're in for a treat. We can’t recommend him highly enough and can’t wait to return for another round of his incredible cocktails and outstanding hospitality the next time we come to Maui !

Plantation House Restaurant is a truly exceptional place to take someone you love. The service, the food and the menu choices are Top Shelf. The wine list includes special wines from many of the world’s most renowned regions and yet still has something for every wine lover. All together they help create a most memorable experience.

The food was fantastic and service was stellar. The real star of the show, however, was the happy hour! Couldn’t believe we got as much food as we did, for such a great price