Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Bargersville

The service, food, ambience, and overall experience at Cake Bake Carmel were fabulous. It was a little loud due to high traffic, but that just means that many people have good taste. Make sure to make a reservation to avoid long wait times and you'll be golden!

This is such a unique and elegant experience. Book a table, put on some nice clothes, and make the drive. From the time you turn into the drive that takes you through the manicured grounds flanked by sculptures to the door of the estate that houses RH, you are transported to one of the most lovely places in Indy. The store itself covers every room with beautiful RH furniture, but the restaurant is spectacular. The menu has everything including different caviar service as well as a modern brunch service with expertly crafted drinks, espresso, and two types of freshly pressed juice drinks. The impossibly thin pancakes and their black Forrest bacon was unlike I’ve had anywhere. My wife had the avocado toast which was very hearty yet light with pickled onions and a salad of parsley and dill. We can’t wait to come back and see the handsome views (not to mention the outdoor furniture) in person when the weather is warmer. Get on the list now!

My wife and I I only go out to a fancy restaurant once or twice a year. We were excited to go to Up Cellar for the first time because it is closer to us on the South Side. It did not disappoint! The food was delicious, the mood and ambiance were perfect, and our server, Taylor, was fantastic! She provided very helpful insight on the menu, was attentive but also gave us time between each course to enjoy our date night, and really helped make the evening special. We had the deviled eggs trio, French onion soup, Denver wagyu steak, duck breast, and bask cheese cake. The eggs and soup were AMAZING! We had never had either wagyu or duck before, and Taylor helped recommend the temperature of the duck for my first time. She suggested Medium, which was a great call. It was very good. Obviously , the wagyu steak was delicious as well. Unlike any steak we’ve ever had. Just melted in your mouth with so much flavor. She helped us decide on the cheesecake for dessert, which was the best choice for the end of that meal. We each had a couple of glasses of wine, and I had the Dark & Smokey cocktail after dinner, which was incredible. Plus, since we were celebrating a late Valentines Day, and my wife’s new job, we each got a complementary glass of champagne! We cannot recommend Up Cellar highly enough! Thanks to everyone there that helped make our night special.

I rave about Our Table every time I go and they keep out doing themselves. The EXPEREINCE is second to none. The staff cares and looks to take care of you. It's so refreshing! The food is fantastic but dining out is more than just the food. Our Table knows that and takes customer service to a new level. My wife tries to stay away from gluten, therefore doesn't eat their delicious bread. We mentioned it to Georgia and she brought out a small cup of white bean hummus with asparagus and carrots. Wow!! It was fantastic... not to mention Georgia was our favorite server, but she has been promoted to manager! Congratulations. She deserves it and did a fantastic job keeping her eyes on things! Kylie was our server and was also so thoughtful and on top of all our needs. I keep saying it... if you haven't been to Our Table, in Bargersville, you are missing out. Make a reservation, or it's first come first serve in the bar area.

Coming back to Indianapolis after many years we made it a point to come to st. Elmo for a celebration with family and we were not disappointed. Our services Will was charming, funny and very knowledgeable about the menu and selection of drinks ( which wow is impressive itself) my husband, brother and sister n law had steak and mashed potatoes I had the South African lobster and my goodness cooked to perfection melted into our mouths .. definitely a treat and the dessert were yummy as well .