Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Orange Park

Mimi, our waitress, was amazing!!! We loved every single thing we ordered. All food presentations and temperature were perfect. We can not wait to go back and will request Mimi.

I booked the Valentine’s dinner for my best friend and myself. We both did the Ruth’s pairing. Not pictured were our Caesar and Steakhouse salads bc we truly demolished them before remembering to take any pictures LOL The steak & shrimp were impeccable. The mashed potatoes were a little unseasoned but that is an easy fix. My French 75 was delicious! The view was amazing & we both received a complementary red rose after our dinner. I also need to give a special shout out to Corey! I had a wardrobe malfunction and he went completely out of his way to ensure that I had the help I needed to continue my day. So thank you so so much to Corey!

Our anniversary dinner was unmatched—from entry to departure. I can’t speak highly enough of the “extra touches” & attention to detail that make dining here an above-par experience. Their florist even reincarnated my wife’s wedding bouquet which was sitting on our table upon arrival. It was literally a spitting image and it brought (happy) tears to my wife’s eyes. It’s absolutely gorgeous. Matthews remains our go-to for all special occasions.