Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Allendale

The chicken parmigiana and chicken saltimbocca were very good. We were overcharged for the mussels compared to the price on the menu. All in all, a good meal. We will return.

Seated quickly at our reservation time, friendly and attentive staff, apps came quickly. Food was delicious except linguini with clams was too salty but everything else was very top notch! Eggplant rollatini, stuffed figs, antipasto, soup, chicken parm, and pistachio cake. Wrapped things up with coffee and sambucca. We will be going back!

It was our first time dining here and we’ll definitely be back! Delicious food, wonderful service and beautiful atmosphere. Thank you for a wonderful Xmas Eve celebration!

Was a fantastic experience for our family of amateur foodies. The 6-course tasting menu was beautifully balanced and creative, with generous portions and gorgeous presentation. We added on 6 oysters and the filet, which was amazing. The service was lovely, with each dish explained as it was served. Will definitely return!

The Saddle River Inn is by far the best restaurant in Bergen county. My guests traveled all the way from Brooklyn, NY, and were absolutely in awe of the entire experience. The Christmas holiday decorations adding an extra layer of magic and charm to the already stunning ambiance. The food was perfection—every dish bursting with flavor and plated beautifully. The entire menu was a hit! Even my foodie guests, who are used to Brooklyn’s top dining spots, couldn’t stop raving about it. With the festive decor, cozy-yet-elegant vibe, and next-level cuisine, the Saddle River Inn made our holiday gathering truly unforgettable.