Best Organic Food Restaurants in Fort Myers Beach

Service was a little bit “off”. It was a Monday after a busy weekend.

We made an online reservation, when we arrived there was no reservation found. They were very accommodating us and sat us down quickly. Great food, there are many gluten free options for celiac with no issues, prompt service, Great ambiance. Loved the market!

Da Michele opened in Fort Myers two months ago and is under the same ownership as Caffe da Michele in Estero. We were personally greeted by the owner, Michele and I was given a long-stemmed rose for Valentine’s Day. Michele wanted all the women there to feel special. It was very sweet. Our server was very friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. We started with wine, a glass of Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cantina Teanum, Puglia and Valpolicella Ripasso Superione, La Sorte, Veneto. Both were quite lovely. With our wine came a basket of bread with olive oil, garlic dipping sauce. We enjoyed both until there was no more! For mains, we ordered Pappardelle alla Bolognese with two meatballs added at our request and Casarecce alla Pugliese (Broccoli Rabe, sausage, garlic , red chill peppers and ricotta salata). Each was fantastic. The atmosphere was especially nice with a man playing the accordion. I really want the word to spread, so that Michele may receive the success he deserves. This restaurant hits all the marks!

We love Mastello. Great wine selections. Food is delicious and fabulous wait staff and owner, Vincenzo. On this night I had the fish special and I should have learned from the past, to not order fish at an Italian restaurant. It was fishy and not nearly as well prepared as other fine dining restaurants known for their fish. Other than that, this restaurant is always wonderful.

Much to our dismay a reservation for an advertised buffet with carving stations /extensive salad bar /appetizers/sides/ desserts became an omelette bar with breakfast sides -which though good , was not what we expected ! apparently the advertised Xmas Buffet was from two years ago and we barely made the cut for the breakfast buffet ! our reservation was for 11 AM and the breakfast Buffet stopped serving at 11 AM. We were seated since we showed our confirmed reservation! Staff was confused n it took a bit to sort it all out. Never have had trouble with open table reservation before but this was a mess!!!