Best Pre-Theater Restaurants in Gramercy Park

Perfect. Whiskey sours delish, burgers done to perfection Waiter werr attentive but not pushy. Ambiance a classic.

Beautiful dinner to celebrate our daughter’s engagement! Thus us our favorite restaurant & very convenient! I had the Bronzini & another ordered salmon & one ordered the turkey & another ordered the ribeye. All were very pleased. They kept the homemade rolls coming & every dessert was fabulous!

Our server Trevor was super attentive and our glasses were never empty! The food was wonderful, my brother said the 12 inch mozzarella stick was the best mozzarella stick he’s ever had. Highly recommend the veggie antipasto and the steak frites, definitely the perfect Christmas Dinner!

We had a very nice dinner last night. We met Tal for the first time. He was very friendly & helpful. All the servers were great. Loved the Dorado & the gnocchi my wife had was especially delicious.

We are not new to Kellari, but that is kind of the point. We visit New York frequently from DC to see theater and eat well. Some of that eating is always done here. The freshness of everything, from the fish to the beefsteak tomatoes on the salads, is remarkable. One always leaves feeling both satisfied and healthier for the experience. This time we had some spanakopita (not to be missed) and a split Greek salad (Oh, those tomatoes!) with a piece of Fagri that was perfectly fresh and exquisitely done. We had a great half-bottle of Brunello, too, from their ample selection of splits, which is great for diners like us who want a taste but can seldom finish a whole bottle. The ambiance is comfortable to the point of being family-like. As for service, it is always stellar and Phillip easily upheld that tradition. We recommend this place to all who are attracted by the menu with the highest measures of confidence and enthusiasm.