Best Restaurants for Birthdays in Mattituck

Lovely holiday decor and overall ambience. Server was efficient, friendly and knowledgeable. Wine selection was very good, perhaps overpriced but that’s eating out generally. Our meal was mediocre, except for the octopus appetizer, which was outstanding. Our main course was a shared branzino from the Canary Islands! Unfortunately, it was a disappointment- very dry with little flavor. The sides were nothing special - roasted but bland. Seasonal root vegetables had carrots, the best part of the main course.

An overall great dining experience - Food was wonderful, Gabby delivered such a pleasant experience and the wine list was diversified and appropriate for most wine lovers. Will certainly go back again.

Dimon Estate is a really lovely place! It has old world charm and a big bonus is that the tables are nicely spaced so you don't feel cramped as one can in many other restaurants. The menu is seasonal although favorites from the previous season were updated to reflect Autumn availability. There are many options to enjoy. We had the eggplant parmigiana (with added shrimp) and shrimp scampi. Of note, the scampi was more of a shrimp marinara over pasta but it was delicious in any event. The service was quite good. Were love bread and wish that they provided some although the portions were ample so we didn't really need it! We will definitely be going back.

Great experience. Service and food first class. Pricey but well worth it. Hand duck, wife had chicken scallapini , son had bass. All outstanding. Some of the best service I ever had