Best Restaurants for Foodies in Amityville

Pietro's as usual was excellent. Food is top notch. The place is decorated beautifully for the holidays. Service was on point. Everything was terrific

our waiter was amazing !! thank you so much for everything

The appetizer sampler was pretty good. Calamari was my favorite. The lamb chops were very small so if you are hungry do not order those. When the restaurant was busy is when we realized there was only 1 waitress for 13 tables. We were neglected for a while and I know she was doing best she could but customers pay good money for service and it was lacking. They did make good on the error and treated us to dessert.

Our servers Kenny and Brianna were excellent. They brought a lot of energy and definitely enhanced the dining experience. They both made recommendations that turned out to be on point. The apps were tremendous, tuna tartare and lobster dumplings. We also had the Halston roll and the Holiday roll which was a special, both were off the charts. Everyone enjoyed their entrees except the bronzing which I was told was dry and an overall swing and a miss. The scampi and ribs were delicious. The PB&J desert was ridiculous.

We had a lovely experience. We were seated at a rear table and it felt nice and relaxing. The food was good, we ordered the 4 course menu again. Always love the cheese and the pretzel bread is perfect. I wish they wouldn't skimp on the sauces for the main part and yes, I know you can tell them but it feels annoying to do so. All in all I recommend this place.