Best Restaurants for Groups in Frenchman's Cay

Whenever I visit the island, a stop at Marmalade and El San Juan is an absolute must. These iconic restaurants truly set the standard for high-end dining, offering an unforgettable culinary experience every single time. The quality of the dishes is nothing short of spectacular. Each plate is a work of art, brimming with bold, eclectic flavors that reflect creativity and precision. The wine pairings are just as stunning, perfectly curated to enhance every bite and elevate the entire meal. What makes the experience even more special is the staff. From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed like an old friend. The team is not only warm and gracious but incredibly knowledgeable, taking the time to explain each dish and recommend pairings that make your experience truly unique. Dining at Marmalade or El San Juan isn’t just a meal; it’s a celebration of flavors, hospitality, and world-class service. I can’t recommend these spots enough for anyone visiting the island!

Excellent experience. The parking is a problem. The lower lot was full and we had a hard time parking. I had to go into the front desk and ask. It is up a very steep hill by the tennis courts. We are 75 and 74 years old and walking up and down a very steep hill was a challenge. They should have valet parking. The hill was like a black diamond slope. LOL. Hard on the knees. Everything else was perfect!!!!

La Tapa was amazing, it truly exceeded our expectations. The food was sublime and the flavors were authentic. The staff were very accommodating to people with allergies also. We had two guests in our group, one with a shellfish allergy and one with a gluten intolerance, but they had many options for both of them that were delicious. Also - the wine pairings!! Trust the staff. La Tapa has prime hospitality and a fun, cultural fusion that is perfect for an evening in St. John!

Excellent experience all around. Beautiful beach setting. Rolling surf. Great food. Friendly staff. Worth every penny

The food, ambiance, and host, Cynthia are all amazing. It truly is an experience in itself, one not to be missed.