Best Sunday Lunch Restaurants in Highbridge

The food was excellent. We thoroughly enjoyed our pasta dish and veal chop which was cooked to perfection. We can say unequivocally that the dishes were outstanding. We do enjoy northern Italian cuisine and have been fortunate enough to frequent good restaurants in Italy. My wife and I highly recommend this cozy neighborhood restaurant.

Pretty place, and obviously popular. Noise level is awful, even in the garden. I was disappointed in the food, as the place was recommended for the food. The French Toast was dry, and not soaked enough or just not enough egg. The omelette was average. It took a long time to get our starter coffees, and at that time the were not full. Later, it became very bus and I know it was harder for the staff.

We love the food and the service at San Matteo. Carmela is so friendly and attentive it feels like dining at a friend’s house.

Great spot for large groups! Not strict on late comers, and had some flexibility with how long we stayed—Typically tables are kept 1.5 hours but they let us stay for 2 hours which was perfect. Our server was very attentive and kind. Really appreciative of our experience here! Food is good, a little pricy for pizzas but honestly to be expected for nyc. Thank you again!

Still a great choice for homey comfort food in a friendly, rustic atmosphere.