Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Rye

We have been for Easter brunch and drinks, but, wanted to go back to try a steak dinner. The space is nice and the staff are pleasant, but, our steaks had sat for quite some time before coming to us. Long enough that my butter didn’t melt on the steak and my mushrooms had started to dry up. We will go again in hopes that this was an off night. If the food had been hot I’m sure it would have been entirely different.

The food was fantastic across the board. The duck is perhaps the best I’ve ever had. The service was also fantastic from start to finish. I highly recommend this place for an upscale dinner.

Christmas Eve dinner was outstanding! Everything was perfect - from the warm service, delicious cocktails and fabulous meal. Thank you!!

The food was excellent. Service was excellent, but the waitress was not friendly. A little smile goes a long way. However, I highly recommend this restaurant.

The restaurant seemed to cater to an older crowd which wasn't bad since I am in my sixties. We were seated at a table that was very wet. When given a drink minute, there were no prices listed. When I asked the server, he didn't know how much they were and said they varied in price. The food was very good with large portions. The price was average-high being at the beach and in a resort hotel. The fisherman's platter was $28. Enjoyed the DJ and dancing in the rear of the restaurant starting at 8pm. All in all we had a good time and would go back.