Best Fun Restaurants in New Buffalo

We were seated 10 minutes early for our 1pm reservation. Out server arrived at our table immediately and greeted us. We put in drink orders then when she came with those we ordered our appetizer and meal. We thought it might take a bit of time as the place was full but it was all out quickly. Ordered thr pot pie and braised beef and both good. This is where service got slow but I think they seated 3 or 4 new tables in her area at once so she was busy. Ordered thr mint cheesecake and that was amazing. Bill was $80 plus tax so not really bad for 2 people to have a nice meal with drinks and dessert. The tree and Christmas decorations were beautiful and we lucked out and were seated near the tree. Will make it a tradition each year to go back. Lucked out on the reservation because we missed it when it opened. So glad we got one!

Matt was our bartender, he's always friendly and pleasant. We always enjoy seeing Wayne when we eat there. Stayed for the music which was very good.

Food was great and so was the service. I have lobster tail and it was cooked perfect. My friend had the lb of king crab legs. She asked if they were split and the waitress said no but we can split them for you. They did a great job. My other friend had the prime rib and it was very tender. The baked potato was huge and the side of mashed potatoes was enough for two people. The lobster bisque was the best I ever had.

We had a wonderful experience at Brewsters …the food was great and prices for the food was reasonable…our waitress “sweet Caroline “ was excellent …very efficient, warm and friendly . We had a very nice experience…thank you Brewsters for being a class A restaurant

Good food, attentive service, we sat upstairs this time , the speakeasy looked interesting maybe next time.