Best Healthy Restaurants in City Island

When we want seafood Limani is our go-to restaurant on the north shore. One of the few places you can get stone crabs by the piece (you pick it, they charge by weight) and a wide selection of fish. Excellent sides available and they are very good about exchanging one side for another if the main course is listed with a side (for example, I switched to lemon potatoes instead of Horta with my fish). The prix fixe dinner available at various times (all night Sunday and Monday) is a good deal but desserts are very limited. Service is usually excellent but this last time staff had to be reminded more than once to bring melted butter for the crab and to bring out the side order of Greek fries after everything else was served. Limani is expensive by LI standards but the quality of the food keeps us coming back.

Pizza is amazing! I had the spaghetti carbonara and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. We also had the salad with arugula and filet. That was 10/10. We always go back to Sarafina’s every trip to New York!! It is always consistent and delicious!

Over the last few years, Nice Matin has become my go to restaurant for that special dinner with my best friend. The food is always excellent, the service is attentive but not too fussy, and the atmosphere is comfortable, friendly, and relaxing.

Delicious lunch fare and dessert. Wonderful tea selection.

Excellent food, staff, and ambiance! Our family had a wonderful time.