Best Historic Restaurants in Little Italy / College St.

37 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Zitto Zitto Taverna restaurant

1. Zitto Zitto Taverna

4.9

Exceptional(161)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Little Italy / College St.

Booked 4 times today

Zitto Zitto Taverna is located in the heart of Toronto’s popular and historic neighbourhood- Little Italy. Upon entering our family owned Taverna, you and your guests will be met by our warm, friendly and fun staff of professionals that will put you at ease and make you feel right at home. Wether you are at the Bar, with its list of Classic Cocktails or in one of our two unique dining rooms, the focus is on providing you with memorable experience, not soon to be forgotten. Accompanied by a fine selection of old and new world wines, Chef Alessandro Militello brings his Sicilian flair to our grill focused menu of fine Italian cuisine that will satisfy a variety of pallets and diets.Make no mistake, owners Anita and Alan's hands on approach will assure all of their guests feel welcome and appreciated. Remember, last reservations for dining may be at 10 PM, but the vibes go on in the Bar!

2. La Bartola

4.7

Exceptional(461)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Little Italy / College St.

Booked 4 times today

In both 2022 and 2023, we received the prestigious Bib Gourmand accolade from the Michelin Guide, making us the first fully plant-based restaurant in Canada to achieve such a distinction.At La Bartola, we take pride in creating an authentic dining experience from scratch. Our corn-based dishes like handmade tortillas, Oaxacan Tetelas, meticulously crafted from non-GMO heirloom corn and traditional Moles, carry the legacy of ancient recipes passed down through generations.Every meal we serve is a tribute to the artistry and time-honoured techniques of Mexican cuisine.Our commitment to using high-quality, traditional ingredients brings flavours to life in unparalleled ways. Each dish tells a story of dedication, honouring the cultural heritage while embracing a plant-based philosophy. Join us on a flavorful journey where each bite is a celebration of artisanal craftsmanship, culinary excellence, and the rich legacy of Mexican gastronomy.

3. DaNico

4.8

Exceptional(274)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Little Italy / College St.

Booked 23 times today

Toronto's highly anticipated dining destination, open in the historic landmark bank building at the heart of the vibrant Palmerston-Little Italy neighborhood.A collaboration between renowned hospitality entrepreneur Nick Di Donato of Liberty Entertainment Group and celebrated Executive Chef and partner Daniele Corona, DaNico redefines the Italian dining experience. Here, contemporary Italian culinary traditions meet exceptional service, unparalleled hospitality, and a bespoke design that sets the stage for a truly unforgettable experience.Michelin-starred Chef Daniele Corona, known for his innovative approach to modern Italian cuisine, blends authentic Italian flavors with subtle Asian influences and techniques, all while showcasing the finest local and sustainable ingredients from across the country. The result is a menu that is as sophisticated as it is memorable, offering guests an extraordinary journey through the best of both Italian and global culinary traditions.

4. Enigma Yorkville

4.8

Exceptional(535)

Price: Very Expensive

• International • Yorkville

Booked 8 times today

Enigma Yorkville is a modern international restaurant nestled on the picturesque St. Thomas Street in Toronto’s historic Yorkville. Under the leadership of Chef Quinton Bennett, whose international resume and well-traveled kitchen team bring a wealth of global influences—from the Nordics to Nihon—Enigma crafts dishes that are delicate, poised, and intricately detailed. Enigma offers a dynamic, seasonal blind tasting menu that seamlessly blends the finest local and international ingredients, delivering a dining experience that is both refined and globally inspired.

5. Sassafraz

4.6

Exceptional(3554)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary Canadian • Yorkville

Booked 25 times today

A beloved local landmark, Sassafraz has welcomed guests to enjoy its contemporary Canadian cuisine, warm hospitality, and unparalleled service for over two decades. Chef Geoff Webb's ever-evolving seasonal menu showcases our relationships with local farms and purveyors. Set in an array of Victorian rowhouses, Sassafraz has evolved through the decades to become a magical space in the heart of historic Yorkville. The iconic little house and its romantic interior make it one of the most stunning restaurants in Toronto.

6. El Catrin

4.5

Awesome(5643)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Distillery District

Booked 77 times today

Situated in the vibrant Distillery Historic District, El Catrin Destileria combines an exciting, tapas-style menu with Canada’s largest collection of mezcal and tequila. Celebrated as one of Toronto’s top dining spots, we offer a fun and lively atmosphere where traditional and modern Mexican cuisine come together for a truly transportive experience. Whether you're celebrating a birthday or enjoying a delightful brunch with friends, our local ingredients and vibrant flavours promise a transportive dining experience. Join us for delicious food, expertly crafted cocktails, and unforgettable moments!

7. Old Mill Toronto

4.5

Awesome(2970)

Price: Very Expensive

• Continental • Etobicoke

Booked 26 times today

Welcome to Old Mill Toronto Dining Room! Join us in our renowned Dining Room at the historic Old Mill Toronto for a memorable dining experience in the west end of the city for fun cocktails and delicious food.If you are looking to reserve Afternoon Tea please follow this link: https://www.opentable.ca/r/afternoon-tea-at-old-mill-toronto-etobicoke.At this time our Hostess desk is closed on Monday Tuesday and Wednesday. We are open Thursday through to Sunday only. We will be returning all calls from Thursday through to Sunday.

8. Joni Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(290)

Price: Expensive

• Farm-to-table • Yorkville

Booked 29 times today

Inspired by the farm-to-table ethos, our restaurant offers a refined culinary experience that celebrates the best of each season, guided by the vision of Chef Jonathan Williams. Paying tribute to the bounty of our region, our dishes are crafted from locally-sourced, sustainable ingredients, highlighting the freshest produce, meats, and seafood—all of which are prepared in house.Chef Williams’ thoughtfully curated menu evolves with the seasons, delivering exceptional flavor combinations that reflect a deep connection to the land. Each plate is a celebration of both simplicity and sophistication, thoughtfully prepared using contemporary techniques that honor the integrity of every ingredient—spanning culinary traditions and techniques from various regions.

9. Cluny

4.5

Awesome(5523)

Price: Expensive

• French • Distillery District

Booked 60 times today

Experience the vibrant charm of Cluny, where modern French cuisine meets unparalleled ambiance in the heart of the Distillery Historic District.Our exciting, unpretentious menus are inspired by France's modern food movement and paired with lively music and breathtaking design. Complement your meal with a selection from our carefully curated wine list, recognized by Wine Spectator and featuring nearly 200 exquisite bottles.For those on the go, our adjacent café offers a delightful array of pastries, macarons, and housemade terrines, perfect for taking a piece of Cluny home. Whether it's freshly brewed coffee or a made-to-order crêpes, our café has something to satisfy every craving.Join us at Cluny for an unforgettable dining experience that blends refined cuisine, personalized service, and an energetic atmosphere. For inquiries or to secure your spot, please call 1-416-203-2632 or email us at reservation@thedistillery.ca.

10. Terroni Adelaide

4.4

Awesome(6966)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Financial District

Booked 93 times today

Terroni Adelaide, formerly the York County Courthouse, is a multi-level heritage structure built in 1852. Just inside the doors is the Enoteca with its towering columns, a great spot for cocktails. Beyond is the main dining room, with a sunlit atrium, fireplaces on each end and private rooms all serviced by an open kitchen where our chefs prepare traditional Italian fare. In summer, the secret garden patio opens for al fresco dining in the heart of the city.Head down to the Cantina Wine Cellar where you will see the original courthouse cells now used to store our Italian wine. The second floor houses the grand Sala da Pranzo and Bar delle Carceri, named after the cells below. Il Covo degli Artisti, our third-floor space is a cosy lounge once home to The Arts and Letters Club where Canadian landscape painters “The Group of Seven” ate and drank in 1909.For information about private parties and reservations for 16+ guests please visit terroni.com to connect with our events team.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

OT
OpenTable DinerVIP
Toronto / Ontario •3 reviews
5.0
Dined today
Wow.. This restaurant left me and my partner absolutely at a loss for words. Before I begin HUGE shout out to the most amazing server I've ever met, Graham. He really curated our experience and brought a personal yet professional level of excitement to our dining experience. Every dish was crafted with immense care and quality. The story behind the dishes and the flavour profile was nothing short of a immaculate dining experiences. Huge thank you to Chef Daniele for exceptional food and a wonderful conversation. We will absolutely be back again soon to go through this culinary journey again. - Eric & Stefania
More info
DaNicoPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Little Italy / College St.
•
4.8
S
Sue
Toronto / Ontario •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Fabulous dinner at La Bartola for my vegan son’s 25th birthday. Excellent professional service by Santana. We had the tastings menu 7 courses - fun way to experience the food. They kindly put a candle in my son’s dessert and brought him a free celebratory glass of sparkling wine without being asked. They also rescheduled our dinner with no problem to a different day with less than 24 hours notice when my son’s flight home was cancelled. All staff and ambience are very charming.
More info
La BartolaPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Little Italy / College St.
•
4.7
H
Hayden
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Had a lovely time, very creative and unique flavors and combinations. Enjoyed the variety of the wait staff, how everyone would come and serve the food, drinks, etc. that yea the open the meal was fantastic. Warm and aromatic and yet sweet and refreshing.
More info
Enigma YorkvillePrice: Very Expensive• International• Yorkville
•
4.8
S
sylviaVIP
Toronto / Ontario •9 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Always perfect. Service, ambience and food are top notch.
More info
Zitto Zitto TavernaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Little Italy / College St.
•
4.9
S
SueVIP
Toronto / Ontario •1 review
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Lately Sassafraz is my restaurant of choice for lunch or dinner due to their great menu and fabulous service! I reserved a table in the dining room but we were seated in the café. The staff were very responsive to our request to move to the dining room and Jeff the GM did everything possible to make amends. We were once again very happy with our meal at Sassafraz and we will be back!!
More info
SassafrazPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Canadian• Yorkville
•
4.6

Best Historic Restaurants in Little Italy / College St.

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

37 restaurants available nearby

1. Zitto Zitto Taverna

2. La Bartola

3. DaNico

4. Enigma Yorkville

5. Sassafraz

6. El Catrin

7. Old Mill Toronto

8. Joni Restaurant

9. Cluny

10. Terroni Adelaide

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable