Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Anna Maria Island

Our kids and grandkids were visiting from CT for Thanksgiving and we thought they would enjoy sitting outside on the water for Thanksgiving dinner (and I didn’t have to cook!). It was a beautiful day. The atmosphere is perfect. Our server, Lynn, greeted us and we learned that she is from our hometown. She was delightful to interact with and was a large part of why the experience was so enjoyable. She made suggestions for draft beers and for dinners for those that didn’t want the traditional holiday meal. The kids had the wasabi tuna and the ribeye and they raved about both of them. The rest of us loved the traditional meal. We agreed that the turkey was the best we ever had and the sides were plentiful and delicious. We have decided that this will be our new Thanksgiving tradition. We couldn’t have been any happier with the experience.

Great spot on Sarasota Bay for delicious seafood and drinks. The grouper sandwich is the best in the area. The outdoor patio is the best setting, where you can watch the boats wander by or come to be stored in the adjacent boathouse. Plan ahead as reservations are scarce and you’ll face long waits without one.

Regulars! Had a wonderful family dinner last night! ❤️

The New building is gorgeous and OMG superb service. We loved David as our head waiter. He has a great personality. The entire staff was absolutely outstanding. We truly felt the love for our special dinner date. -champagne toast 5 -special dinner photo 5 -Caesar and lemon vinaigrette salads 5 - bread and butters 5 -Tomahawk 5 -Flemings potatoes 5 -corn brûlée 5 -cheesecake 5 -gooey brownie/ice cream 5 OVERALL- We will definitely be back. Thank you for an excellent evening.

Cal our waiter was awesome. She made sure everything was great