Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in East Indy

This is easily one of THE places to go in Indiana! If you are looking for that “special occasion “ place, Catello’s consistently delivers. Service and ambience are always 5 star! And if you want Italian, REAL Italian with homemade pasta and cheeses, nothing else in Indiana comes close.

Love this restaurant!! Always great food, great service and memorable. Thank you!

First time @ St. Elmo’s. Service was excellent. History behind building/restaurant very interesting! Meals were excellent & desert wonderful. Will definitely be back for next special occasion/celebration

Our meal was a family celebration and everything was perfect. We appreciated the seating arrangements. The food was exceptional. Our server was friendly, attentive, and met every request we had.

This was a family Christmas/birthday celebration. One of our members has celiac and therefore gluten free. This was noted in our reservation. Staff was aware and very accommodating. There was a gluten-free menu, but we also were told by the manager (who double checked our order with us) that many of the other selections could be made gluten-free and all we had to do was ask. Staff was attentive but not intrusive. The food was excellent/amazing and although I would never consider this inexpensive or even moderate every penny as well worth it.