5 Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Lake Mary

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse restaurant

1. F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(380)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Heathrow

Booked 27 times today

One important factor that sets F&D Prime aside from other restaurants is our Prime Aged Steak Program. We proudly serve only custom aged USDA Prime steaks from our privately managed inventory. F & D Prime has made a major commitment to serving beef items that are derived from some of the best livestock money can buy.After going through this custom aging process, the end result is a truly memorable steak in both flavor and texture. A steak that the guests will remember and bring them back time and again. At F&D Prime, we take pride in offering a dining experience like no other, and our dedication to quality and taste sets us apart from the rest.

A photo of Enzo's on the Lake restaurant

2. Enzo's on the Lake

4.7

Exceptional(3128)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Longwood

Booked 23 times today

Enzo's on the Lake is the perfect place for an evening of cocktails, fine food and wine, delicious desserts and very special hospitality. In 1980, Enzo's on the Lake opened as a lovely secluded lakefront restaurant, built in the style of an Italian villa. The restaurant is dedicated to the idea of simple yet sophisticated cuisine: family owned, crafted with love. The freshest fish, meats, fruits and vegetables that can be obtained are woven into a menu that emphasizes a unique culinary heritage. An antipasto bar welcomes you to the excitement of the dining room overlooking the lake. There is a full service european style bar, private dining areas for meetings and parties, and lakeside gardens and dock. We look forward to serving you!

3. Jazz Tastings

4.8

Exceptional(651)

Price: Expensive

• American • Maitland

Booked 13 times today

• $10 Entertainment Fee Per Person on Friday, Saturday & Monday Night Jazz Jam (first Monday of the month)• • $25 Minimum Food & Beverage Purchase Per Person Monday-Thursday•• $50 Minimum Food & Beverage Purchase Per Person for on Friday & Saturday•• Friday & Saturday: Reservations available until 7:30pm, after that time we accept walk ins only!••Parties of 7 or more must purchase a group package, contact us at 407-795-1582•**If minimums are not met you will be charged the remaining balance**Weekly Deals:Happy Hour Tuesday-Thursday from 5:30pm-7pm: Half off appetizersTuesday- Burger & Brew $15, 1/2 off Wine Bottles all night!Wednesday- 1/2 off select Whiskey & Wine all night!Located in Maitland, Florida, Jazz Tastings combines the intimate atmosphere of a jazz bar with a classy menu. There is also an impressive alcohol list to enjoy along with the soothing music and great food.

A photo of Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen - Altamonte Springs restaurant

4. Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen - Altamonte Springs

4.6

Exceptional(141)

Price: Moderate

• Creole / Cajun / Southern • Altamonte Springs

Booked 7 times today

Tibby’s New Orleans Kitchen has been serving authentic New Orleans cuisine for over a decade, earning countless awards and a feature on The Food Network. Our menu is packed with New Orleans classics, from gumbos and jambalaya to po’ boys and our famous beignets. Signature dishes like Rita’s Chicken and Pasta Monica bring bold Southern flavors to life. Join us for weekend brunch, featuring bottomless mimosas, sangria, Bloody Marys, and draft beers. Plus, live music every Sunday brunch makes for an unforgettable experience. Whether you're craving the best Cajun food or looking to celebrate Mardi Gras all year, Tibby’s delivers the true soul of New Orleans in every bite.Happy Hour is every day from 4-6pm!

A photo of Antonio's - Maitland - Upstairs restaurant

5. Antonio's - Maitland - Upstairs

4.7

Exceptional(1828)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Maitland

Booked 13 times today

Antonio's has built a reputation for high quality, great value and friendly service. Our menu features authentic Northern and Coastal Italian cuisine. We prepare a wide variety of original seafood, veal, steaks and pastas with the freshest ingredients, at competitive prices. To complete your experience we offer an extensive bottle wine list, a full liquor bar and warm, gracious service in a comfortable and elegant atmosphere overlooking Lake Lily.

Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Lake Mary

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse

2. Enzo's on the Lake

3. Jazz Tastings

4. Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen - Altamonte Springs

5. Antonio's - Maitland - Upstairs

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable