Restaurants near The Oldest House

We visited the Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine on Christmas Eve, and it was a truly special experience. The restaurant’s Spanish colonial décor was beautifully enhanced with holiday decorations, creating a warm and festive atmosphere that perfectly complemented the charm of St. Augustine during the season. We started with the Croquettes de Pollo as an appetizer, and they were fantastic—crispy on the outside, creamy and flavorful on the inside, with the perfect balance of chicken and béchamel. For my entrée, I chose the Bambino, a hearty and flavorful dish. The slow-cooked beef was tender and well-seasoned, paired beautifully with the rich tomato sauce and yellow rice. Each bite was comfort food at its finest. Even on such a busy evening, the service was top-notch. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and ensured we had everything we needed to enjoy a wonderful holiday meal. Dining at the Columbia Restaurant on Christmas Eve was a memorable experience that blended outstanding food, impeccable service, and the magic of the season. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy the history, charm, and cuisine of St. Augustine. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

What can I say? Overall a wonderful experience with the food, presentation, and service. We live up in Nocatee and travel the world looking for culinary delights. Well,,, guess what- we have one in our backyard! We will be back many times!

Our party was a little early for our reservation, however we were seated immediately. We were given light-up holiday hats for everyone in the party because we made a reservation online. So cool! The ambiance was lovely, all decorated for Christmas, a cool little bar, and awesome holiday themed cocktails. The waiter was very attentive. Amazing food! Get the burger! One of the best burgers I’ve ever had! The shrimp bisque was also quite good. My only negative is the price, but I’d rather spend $150 for a meal that supports a small business, with quality hand-crafted food than pay the same for a chain restaurant of the same predictable menu items. We love St. Augustine and come up every December for Night of Lights. We hope to visit Forgotten Tonic again next year!

First time experience and will definitely return! Friendly and professional greeting upon arrival. Mikayla was awesome and ensured that we were good with everything! She was also very personable and professional! Thanks team!

We had an awesome girls night out!!! The variety of food for all tastes was perfect, and the cocktails are made to perfection!! Management was present and all of the staff were so helpful and attentive