Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
5 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- DdonnaNew York City •10 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoThis restaurants consistency is unsurpassed. Food delicious plus great vibe and good pricing. Something that is hard to find in this community. The service was so friendly and attentive and for the value it’s one of the best restaurants of its kind. The menu is really diverse and interesting and their specials weekly are just amazing. Dining room ambience cozy and airy.More infoVine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island•4.7
- CCarol ZimmerNew York City •8 reviews4.0Dined 3 days agoDelicious halibut special entree, and scrumptious crab cake app w-salsa. Great food, local vibe, always a great time.More infoSophie's Rest.Price: Moderate• American• Southold•4.7
- HhalVIPNew York City •32 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoNever a bad meal, always wonderful service with delicious food…More infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.6
- SScottVIPNew York City •57 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoAn absolute exquisite dining experience with incredible service, fine wines, and a wonderful cozy atmosphere. This is absolutely my favorite restaurant! Is the only place that I go where I never put anything on the steak. No salt or pepper or anything. The way it is seasoned and the way it comes is perfect every time. I’ve been going to J. Gilbert for 25 years and it’s amazing that I’ve never had to send anything back to the kitchen. They are so careful in their preparation and so precise. Such high-quality food. It’s also the restaurant I go to for every one of my birthdays!More infoJ. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood – GlastonburyPrice: Expensive• Steak• Glastonbury•4.8
- JJillVIPNew York City •12 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoWe had an absolutely fantastic experience at Halyard. From the moment we arrived, the service was warm, friendly, and incredibly attentive, making us feel truly welcomed. The food was just as impressive—each dish was thoughtfully prepared and bursting with flavor. We started with the tuna tartare and the calamari, which came with a delightful surprise—perfectly blistered shishito peppers that added just the right amount of heat. For our main course, the halibut was cooked to perfection, and the Brussels sprouts were crispy and full of flavor. The cheese-laced mashed potatoes were an indulgent, creamy dream. Dessert was an espresso-infused crème brûlée that was both unexpected and absolutely delicious. Halyard exceeded our expectations in every way.More infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport•4.5
Discover best neighborhood gem restaurants in Shelter Island
Discover the charm of Shelter Island's dining scene, where each restaurant shines as a "neighborhood gem" offering unique and delightful experiences. Shelter Island, a serene and picturesque locale in Suffolk, New York, boasts a variety of dining establishments that are perfect for both casual and sophisticated tastes. These restaurants are celebrated for their commitment to quality, with many emphasizing locally-sourced ingredients and inventive dishes that reflect the area's culinary diversity. Patrons can expect warm, inviting atmospheres coupled with service that's both attentive and personable, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner or a friendly venue for a family gathering, Shelter Island's restaurants cater to all occasions with excellence and charm. The dining scene here is a testament to the community's passion for good food and genuine hospitality, making it a true destination for food lovers. Each restaurant not only meets the expectations of locals and visitors but also contributes to the island's reputation as a culinary haven in Suffolk.