Best Steak Restaurants in Middleton

Our 3rd dining experience at Post 1917 and it continues to exceed our expectations. It is an energetic crowd that appreciates quality food and drinks. It is not inexpensive, but worth the value. The chicken parm plate is fit for 2 people and the surf & turf combo of filet/lobster tail was terrific. We will be back...

While pricey, La Fina is a top restaurant with impeccable food and service. Kind and friendly (not stuffy) atmosphere Management walking around, offering kind words, very visible

The entire experience was fantastic from drinks and apps to dessert. Food was top notch and our server Louis awesome! He made the experience great just as much as the food.

A perfect birthday dinner from start to finish! Impeccable service and outstanding food and drink. Hubby’s Ribeye was the best steak either one of us has ever tasted. We were seated near the fireplace and the ambiance was warm and festive. We have been here several times and while the experience is always a great one, this one was exceptional. We sadly had no room for dessert, but our waiter Jacob sent us home with two chocolate truffles which was a very nice touch. We will certainly be back.

Theresa's Prime is one of our favorite date night places. The food is always excellent quality, prepared well and to our liking. All of the servers and restaurant staff are well trained, polite, and very helpful. We especially enjoyed having Alan last week. He always takes great care of us and makes spot on suggestions. He gives us the right amount of attention and makes us feel special. I got the surf and turf which was a filet with their own steak sauce and 2 baked stuffed shrimp topped with asparagus. My husband got the filet. We found everything absolutely delicious. When a restaurant knows how to treat their customers, has fantastic food, and really nice ambiance you keep going back. Theresa's Prime does just that and more. We hope to get back there real soon!