Best Italian Restaurants in Garden City

Santa Lucia never fails to provide a great pizza, piping hot. Our guests also enjoyed the Gyro and Salads. We'll be back again!

Great new menu. Food was very good, as was the service.

Nice restaurant, appetizer was really good (steak tartare), they missed on the Carbonara. It’s was okay, the service was fantastic. Very friendly staff, would definitely go again.

It was our first time there. My son used to order through Skip to his apartment, but never went to the restaurant itself. He loved the food. So when we asked him to pick a spot for his birthday, he chose this restaurant as he hadn't ordered for awhile due to budget. We went at 4:30pm on a thursday so it was very quiet, the hostess was pleasant and didn't cling to oiur table, but would check in every now and then, which was great. Food came hot and fresh with loads of flavor. Will definitely make a trip to this restaurant again.

The service, ambience and setting was lovely! Cocktails and mock tails exactly what we ordered. The food was well prepared, be prepared for pasta Al dente. Wine suggestion was superb. Don’t skip dessert.