Best Steakhouses in Locust Valley

Exception experience for my husband and i celebrating our anniversary.

Valet was fast and professional. Bar area and service was nice. Manager/host was very pleasant and accommodating, seated us quicky, at a nice table, although we were still waiting on one more to join our party. Waitress was great. Food was delicious, one of the best steaks I'd ever eaten. Restaurant was a tad bit dark for me, dimly lit, but that's just me. Otherwise, and overall wonderful experience.

Great steakhouse with an old school feel. The wait staff is very attentive and you never have an empty glass or dirty dishes on the table waiting to be cleared. The food is great. Can’t wait to go back.

This is an update to a previous post where I gave a zero rating. I had the opportunity to dine here once again. Since my last dining experience, they hired a new General Manager to correct the issues they were having. While the food before was sub par there certainly has been a marked improvement and is excellent. The terrible service we had prior was a completed turn around. Juan and Lin treated us if we were family and royalty. Their attention not only to us but every other diner around us was impeccable. The new General Manager Joey came to the table several times making sure both the food and service was up to Scotto’s standards. My previous rating of zero is now a 5. Joey, Juan and Lin made sure our dining experience was top notch and an enjoyable evening both by the service and food. I will definetly go back.

Spectacular dining experience in a beautiful, comfortable restaurant. Ideal for any occasion from a romantic dinner for two, family celebration or business meeting. Attentive, friendly waitstaff. Wonderful menu with a selection of appetizers, entrees and desserts to suit any palate from sushi, to pasta, steaks and more. A must go to restaurant!